Reviews for La Tinajita Pizzeria Cubana in West New York, NJ

Delicious Cuban pizza! Only downside is that no beer or wine is available .

Rey, the owner is very friendly and polite his employees very nice persons,but the best things are the quality of type of ????... but my favorite is the lobster, shrimp and Hawaiian. GOD CONTINUES BLESSINGS LA TINAJITA and my best friend Rey. Read more

Cuban pizza visited this 0lace with two cubans that just got to America less than a year ago and they both indicated it was the... closest to authentic Cuban pizza. Read more

Honestly, I've been coming to this place since I was 2-3 years old. I am 22 now, and I still love this place! But.. Their... quality has gone down quite a bit in the past year or so. I understand because of the pandemic, but their pizza's have gottensmaller, their spaghetti has gotten thinner, and their sauce is very watery now, and doesnt even coat the whole spaghetti. LikeI said, I love this place, but they need to do a bit better. Read more

When I lived in WNY I LOVED coming here!! Especially for their pan pizza in which I?m craving one so bad but I now live in... Texas!! Check this place out you won?t regret it Read more

Havent had the pleasure to eat in the store yet, but me and the guys from work order there at least once a week, and we usually... order an extra pie each to take home for the wife or even ourselves the next day. I usually order a Hawaiian and a Mixta pie.Delicious food and fast delivery. Read more

Best Cuban pizza! Closest think to the local pizzeria in the small town my family is from. Service is okay, but the delicious... pizza is worth it. We both ordered the ham, which is what I always get. Read more

I wish my opinion was different. As a cuban, eating pizza and pasta the cuban style is enjoyable,when it is good. I ordered a... jam pizza and espaggetti with an aurora cheese cream for delivery 1.5 miles away because im a truck driver. Gave the driver 25dollars for an 18 dollar check and when i opened the food it was horrible. It was not cheese cream it was a cheese milkshakewith out the cheese. Just the color. The pasta was not even mixed. The jam,souce and cheese in cups. Like thats going to meltand mix nicely after 40 mins driving around in the delivery car. The pizza. My god. You can fit the personal pizza in thealuminum plate twice. Hard. Dry and cold. Im sorry but never again. The only good thing was the cold koka kola can. Tiene quetrabajar muchisimo para llamarse pizzeria cubana. Tremenda basura Read more