Reviews for Sal's Pizzeria in West New York, NJ
the pizza was absolutely disgusting. the cheese tasted like it was weeks old. sauce had no flavor and the dough was chewy
Juicy, flavorful, HOT!!!! Oh my goodness! I left NO crumbs or leftovers ????????
Horrible customer service I ordered 3 pies one pepperoni one with olives and peppers and one Hawaiian I did not get Hawaiian I... got a plain one I called to ask for my pie and the girl that answered was nasty she said she gave me Hawaiian but I havepictures. The pizza is good customer service is horrible I won?t ever order from there again Read more
Pizza is already delicious. No complaints one bit. It's always consistent. From the cheeses sauce and bread. Never talk thick or... too thin. Love it. Recomm the to anyone Read more
Gave me food poisoning. Never ordering again. Food used to be good but it's gone down in quality. Pizza tasted thick and doughy,... which isn't what I ordered. Don't bother with the old reviews. Whatever they've changed recently has ruined their pizzeria. Read more
Everytime I go to Sal's Pizzeria they never disappoint!! The half pepperoni & cheese pie was freshly made, very tasty and... cheesy!!! This is why they are the best pizza in town for sure!!! I recommend this Pizzeria to anyone that wants to eat amazingpizza!!! Read more
Great Pizza.... ???? and not soggy or limp Very hard to fine a good Pizza that doesn't bend on your hand... Late visit but they... let me eat in...friendly and very welcoming really enjoyed and with my most to have topping.... take a closed look... Will comeback..???? Read more
I love sals but I?m giving them 3 stars today because for the past two years I?ve lived here I?ve always ordered a large pie... half marg and half white/broccoli & when I tried to order tonight they told me they couldn?t do it simply because the ownerdoesn?t like to to do it. That?s my favorite thing to order from them & im really disappointed this is the first time they haveever denied it. Read more