Reviews for Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill in West Palm Beach, FL

Update: 11/16/22-Steak Tip Appetizer-absolutely delicious! If you haven?t ordered the Steak Tip Appetizer or the dinner you need... to! The steak tips are so tender and juicy-like nothing I?ve ever had before! The flavor is amazing! They literally melt in yourmouth.. The appetizer is served with one onion ring and the onion ring is crispy and a perfect topping for the 4 tips! For meit?s a meal I savor.. as always from the minute I walk through the door I am greeted warmly like family. As a widow I findEatalia as my safe happy place. The feeling like family is priceless! From the owners Nadia and Al to their unbelievablydedicated staff you feel welcomed! The atmosphere is of family, fun with fabulous food made with lots of love! The service isalways friendly, professional and amazing! So thankful Eatalia is around the corner but I would drive hours to be here.. Pleasesupport our local family owned and operated restaurants! June 7, 2022-My favorite restaurant on my day off with Puppy! Outsideseating is perfect! Late lunch! Completely covered out of the sun with a nice East West breeze even when it?s hot outside!Monique and Michael are amazing! Welcoming and you always feel like family! They just had a packed restaurant for lunch on aTuesday! That truly speaks to how amazing the food and service is!! Monique appears with a cold crisp Pinot Grigio for me! Wow!Fabulous! I ordered my newest favorite ? Greek Salad with Grilled Shrimp! (Refer to my pictures) It?s huge with 5 very largegrilled shrimp! I took half home! I also took home their decadent Big Dig chocolate cake! You must have dessert or take it home!Homemade desserts are delicious! It always feels like home! Can?t wait till my next day off! May 9, 2022: Eatalia is thequintessential restaurant for all tastes! Sometimes you have to renew your love of wings! Yes, wings! Eatalia has the mostdelicious variety of wings in the State! I love their breaded wings, flats only.. They are served piping hot and cr Read more

Always like coming to your Grandma's Kitchen. Even the ice tea is delicious. Love the Alfredo here. So many things are homemade... just like you would expect Grandma to do. Place feels and tastes like home. Always amazing staff that take care of you hear aswell. I can't say enough good things about this place. Highly recommend it Read more

Jenny, the bartender, can make a margarita to impress the most discerning Texan visitors that love margaritas. Nonna?s Lasagna... is also incredible. Will be coming back the next time I visit West Palm Beach! Read more

I ordered delivery today sept. 20, 2022. The food arrived looking less than appetizing. The small pizza I ordered just taste... like straight salt. I am upset that I spent money here. I must look elsewhere for my dinner tonight. Read more

I ordered a fresh out the oven small cheese pizza, I got a small cheese pizza that looks like it has been sitting out for a... while, the cheese was not piping hot, tomato sauce looked dry and I was able to not only pick up a slice, but also take a bite(something you would not be able to do with any fresh out the oven pizza). Would definitely NOT recommend. This is a close up ofthe pizza that I received.....SMH! NEVER AGAIN! Read more

We have given Eatalia about 4 chances between eating there and ordering through delivery. I would say there was one time we were... actually pleased. There is just no consistency. The entrees are small portions, I have never seen a restaurant skimp on pastathe cheapest food item. I just ordered pizza tonight because last time it was actually pretty good, so I figured why not, and itwas truly disappointing. Me, my mom, and husband all said we should have just ordered from Anthony?s. I really wanted to likethis place but there are better options for Italian. Read more

As a discerning New Yorker and an even pickier eater (especially of Italian cuisine), I can honestly say Eatalia is one of the... very few restaurants in the area that has consistently top quality, authentic and super fresh Italian food, amazing customerservice, a welcoming family vibe, and never disappoints. The restaurant is meticulous, the food is always homemade, and theynever fail to deliver the best! They take such immense pride in their food and truly love their customers. I eat here weekly andtell everyone to come here. It cannot be beat! Jenny and Monique are sweethearts and the owners Al and Nadia strive forexcellence and never waiver. They are THE BEST! I never write reviews and this one is long overdue. Thank you guys foreverything. A true ?home away from home.? Read more

We order from here about once a week and the food is always great. We?ve tried the large meat lovers pizza, chicken parm,... chicken Marsala, baked ziti, penne ala vodka with grilled chicken, meatball parm sub, and garlic knots are all great. The owneris always there and she makes great food and takes care of her customers (we had a slight delivery issue and she stepped rightup). Very impressed with the food and the way she runs her business. Our go to for Italian food in West Palm Beach!! Read more