Reviews for One Pie Pizza Co in West Seneca, NY
Can?t believe I lived 10 min away from here and have never tried their pizza. This will definitely become my go to spot! The... store is clean, service is excellent and the pizza ???? is delicious. The perfect harmony of sweet to savory and they don?tskimp out on the pepperoni. I?ll have to work my way through the menu. 10/10 you can really tell it?s made to order withquality ingredients and the owner is proud of his work. Support local. Read more
I'm not sure where to begin on this pizza. I'll just start by saying it's excellent. Obviously, that's subjective, but, I love... this pizza! If you don't like a sweeter pizza sauce, this isn't for you! The sauce is indeed sweet, but very flavorful. Thecrust is like a Pizza Hut Pan Pizza, but thinner and not as greasy. Again, my opinion, but the crust is excellent, and unlikeany other I've had. All ingredients on this Pizza are QUALITY! You can taste the quality hands-down... Its unequivocal. Thepepperoni is the real-deal that curls up when cooked. Again, quality! Their blu-cheese is homemade, and is again, excellent! Ifyou like a sweeter sauce, DO NOT hesitate to try this pizza! Read more
I tried this place for the first time yesterday, and it was very good! The parking leaves something to be desired, but the owner... was pleasant and friendly, the pizza (which is a large, pan-type slice) was delicious and hot, and the blue cheese was prettygood, but too tangy and tasted pretty basic (NOTE: it is a homemade blue cheese, according to the owner). I will be going backto try more, and was overall happy with my first experience! Read more
Honestly probably some of the best pizza I've ever had
I had high hopes, but in the end this pizza just wasn't for us. Yesterday we ordered the "2 PEP CONVERSION". It sure looked... good, but none of us liked the crust. The crust is thin and VERY hard. I tried cutting up a few pieces and even with our steakknives I was breaking into a sweat. Some may enjoy a hard thin crust - if so, then U will probably like the pizza here becausethe rest of the pie was good. (BTW, just in case U missed it on some other reviews - their sauce is very sweet.) Also - a wordof caution - I ordered this yesterday at 6:25 pm, and they said I was lucky because I was the last order of the night! I askedwhy that was??? Apparently they only prep so many pizza doughs for the whole day and once they're gone - THEY'RE GONE - so orderearly!! Read more
This Is a fantastic pizza place, that very few people seem to know about. And that's a mistake. You should learn about it, it is... well worth the trip. My favorite part is their attitude towards pizza. They make the dough, when they run out of dough... Theyhave no more pizza. They make it fresh everyday, it's not frozen nonsense Cisco food special... Sweet sauce, and crust that isthick, but not chewy/doughy. Read more
Delicious! Classic Buffalo pie but tightened up. Fresh ingredients, hand-cut pepperoni, airy crust with a nicely done crisp... undercarriage. No slop, undercooked dough, or excess grease. They have a reward program for repeat customers. Very clean insideand friendly service. I will be back. Check it out. Read more
Absolutely loved loved loved this place. I say loved because I moved out of state but I think of this place all the time. The... service in the shop was incredible, I always loved talking with my girls that took my order, and so was the pizza. I went thereso much they eventually knew my order [2 slices and a soda] and what time I was coming [6:30/6:45] because I went there almosteveryday on my lunch. I cannot say enough good things about this place; if you're thinking about it.. just go. Oh and tryyour pepperoni with Blue Cheese, thank me later ???? ????. Read more