Reviews for Main Street Creamery & Cafe in Wethersfield, CT
Awesome creamy and delicious ice cream. Atleast 20+ flavors ranging from the basics to a few more extreme choices. Tried the... flight of ice cream for multiple flavors. You end up getting more ice cream for less with this sample $9 for for a flight vs $5a scoop ???? Read more
Love this local ice cream shop. It's in a beautiful part of old Wethersfield and I come often. They have a variety of flavors... and they rotate constantly. Taking a star off though just to warn that depending on the employee you get determines if you'llenjoy your experience or not. Most of the time I am satisfied, but there are times like tonight where I was given literal icecream soup the size of a small when I ordered a medium. I've had other experiences that are mediocre, but mainly great ones. Read more
WOW- Totally worth a detour of the highway to stop here - it's literally about 3 minutes from the exit and the line is OUT THE... DOOR. Not only did they have amazing ice cream and baked goods, they have both VEGAN and GLUTEN FREE OPTIONS... including CONES!WOW upon WOW - Beautiful little New England town and gorgeous summer stop to remind you of the historical roots of our greatcountry. The downtown looks like you time-travelled back to the 1750s - It's clean and so fun. Read more
My wife had the Cold brew float (with vanilla ice cream) and ofc I had the Cookie Monster ice cream on a waffle cone. If you are... a coffee lover you would for sure enjoy this. You can ask for a shot of espresso for $2 more. The Cookie Monster was delicious,not the best I have ever had but creamy and soft. Had a very smooth texture and just enough cookie pieces inside the ice cream.Please make sure you bring cash as they only accept that or Venmo as a form of payment. Read more
Great family place for ice cream. They have tons of flavors and fun toppings to choose from. I like that it?s right on Main... Street, there?s tons of places in the area to sit. The ice cream is extremely rich, so be cautious on how much you order. It?salso cash or Venmo only, they have an ATM available inside. Read more
Very cute place. Many different flavors to choose from, reasonable prices. Very friendly customer service.
I happened to be in the area & had heard of Main St Creamery...& that they have vegan options...so I decided to give them a... try. It's located in a quaint little area, in a cute little blue w/white trim cottage-like structure. I didn't know/realizethat they were strictly cash/Venmo & have an ATM inside. Generally I don't support businesses that are cash only????... bcuz whoactually ever has cash on them these days??? ???? But somehow I happened to have just enough for a healthy sized taste of allfour flavors available today. {I really wish that businesses would stop doing this practice...makes me wonder about a fewethical issues...AND I ABSOLUTELY REFUSE to get "robbed" at ANY ATM {a.k.a. fees} so really hope businesses rethink thisstrategy. So bcuz of THIS I knocked 2 stars off, as cash ONLY is a HUGE inconvenience..& i don't want to be "forced" to doeither of the other 2 "options"... otherwise I'd given them a better score. But today they had: Cookie Dough, Vanilla,Chocolate Peanut Butter, & Chocolate Vegan "ice cream" ???? If you've never considered and/or ever had vegan "ice cream,"you're DEFINITELY missing out!!! This "ice cream" is flavorful, creamy & tasty! I wouldn't have it everyday, as my scale wouldlaugh at me daily. ???????? They also had 3-4 sorbets, which I decided to skip today. But even those sounded delish...from whatI can recall of their names...pink lemonade something, coconut, & ??? But again all sounded very tempting! If/when they dropthe cash/etc only "options" I'd like to come back...but that's me! Read more
We enjoyed our experience at Main Street Creamery. The flight is a good deal and great for sharing or for the indecisive ice... cream customer (@ me). Our favorite flavors were the pumpkin Oreo and coffee Oreo. We thought the texture of the apple caramelcrumble was a bit icy/gritty and not as creamy as the other flavors Read more