Reviews for The Bay Restaurant in Whitefish Bay, WI
Lovely atmosphere. Was very busy when I was there with 4 friends, but service was great, food came out very quickly and it was... delicious. Read more
Great lunch menu. BLT was quite good and their homemade potato chips were outstanding!
I had ordered the ham sandwich and my wife and her sister had the grilled cheese loaded with bacon and tomato. We were very... pleased with our meal. Prices were good. The girl who served us was great and although it was very busy she did awesome. Woulddefinitely recommend this restaurant. Read more
This place is cute and in the heart of downtown white fish bay. We just moved to the neighborhood and we were excited to try... this place. We liked everything about this place except the food. Cheddar cheese on pizza???? My salad was canned fruit. Iwondered if my fries were frozen crinkle fries. Pretty certain they were. For being in such a nice area this was really lackluster. Want the best for any restaurant, hope they consider revamping the menu and using fresh food. Read more
The Bay Restaurant is a sure win when you swing on by. My favorite Hour is Happy Hour and they've got fantastic cocktails with... great food; what more could you ask for?!!!! When you step in ask for Sally and tell her Molly sent you. Read more
A great resturant and absolutely great atmosphere, James and Kevin and the rest of the team work so hard and it shows. The food... is spectacular. I have not had anything miss off of this menu with the many times I've visited. Great date spot. Awesome outsideseating and just a great vibe throughout. Love the bay! Read more
The chili was very good it had the right amount spice for a chili. The food came out hot. Chicken wrap was good also. The pizza... my date got was not worth the price whatsoever. But the burger he got he said it was on point (great)! Ultimately the food wasgood especially for a lunch date. Read more
Went here with my wife and daughter. The food was great. The pasta dish, like a Cajun Mac and cheese with peppers, olives, and... chicken was absolutely delicious. The ingredients sound like an odd combination but the taste was amazing. Service was good. Myonly complaints: the tap selection was seriously lacking. And when I got my bill, there was a "bar tax". What the hell is a bartax? I've never seen this on a dining bill before. I'd have given this place a higher rating had they disclosed the additionaltax up front, and had a better drink selection. Read more