Reviews for Tony's Pizzeria & Deli Whitesboro in Whitesboro, NY

Ordered hot subs. Showed up a bit later than the time they suggested to pick up and still waited a while. not sure what... happened. The subs were good. Read more

Very clean place, food is always consistent and delicious!

The upside down pizza taste really good along with her sauce. Chicken wings are OK and the subs. There is a little bit to be... desired. Read more

Always friendly. Wings are amazing. You ask for extra crispy and you actually get extra crispy! Pizza never disappoints.

Tony's has delicious pizza. Prices are compatible with other pizzerias but consistency is #1.

Had a gift card to use up so stopped in for some slices and the Best pusties In town!!! Nice neighborhood pizzaria , pleasant... staff Read more

This pizza was amazing... the sauce had a sweetness to it. The topping were evenly spread across the pie with a sense of the... artist wanted the eater to savor flavors of everything in each bite. I love mushroom and green peppers, but I have no doubtsthat they take the care in making each pie. With that said I lowered a star because when I made order the young lady who tookmy order seemed like I was a bother and she ws very offputting to me. She seemed very dissatisfied with her job and I feel doesnot represent the pizzeria as a whole. I guess attitude towards customers is key when one walks in to the establishment. Therewas no personality to the service. Food was amazing. Will get pizza here again, but may call first. Read more

Stopped at this location for a quick slice. Excellent selection, quick service, and tasted great. Friendly staff and to my... surprise, not all Tony's Pizza's in the utica/whitsboro/new Hartford area are the same. They may appear Similar, but the qualityvaries in every location I've been to. Not to mention the staff in one particular location (NOT THIS ONE) needs better peopleskills. Read more