Reviews for Cafè Calamari in Williams Bay, WI
Delicious! Delicious! Delicious! Definitely recommend this restaurant! The calamari was exquisite! My pesto primavera was... amazing as well! Read more
Lived in the area for 28 years and have never been to Cafe Calamari. Absolutely lived this resturant. Great atmosphere along... with a creative menu for seafood and steaks. We started with the Calamari appetizer which was delicious. I had the 16. Oz Bonein Veal Chop special and my wife had the Crab encrusted Chilean Sea Bass with Lobster Cream Sauce. Both entries wereoutstanding. We finished the meal with Taramisu and Espresso Gelloto. I'm giving this best meal of 2022... Read more
We love Cafè Calamari. The food is delicious. They were able to accommodate our 9 person party. The wine & whiskey selection is... top notch. I ordered oysters to start and built a pasta dish to finish. ???????????? Excellent professional service every time. Read more
A very busy restaurant, strongly recommend making a reservation. They have a wonderful outdoor seating area. Great service. We... ordered the pasta bolognese, it was good, but short on sauce. The cheese strudel was delish. We ordered Tito lemon dropmartinis, they were short filled, good, but for $13.50 each to fill the glass half way was ridiculous. I would return, butwon't order martinis again. Read more
Love, Cafe Calamari restaurant in Williams Bay, WI … whether indoors/outdoor patio has an ambiance atmosphere you’ll want to... dine -in & experience this beautiful view of the lake/inside by the fireplace w/lights. The food is delicious too! Read more
We came by across this place by accident and I'm so glad we did. The ambiance, service everything was amazing. Best Rockefeller... oysters I've ever had. They made our wedding anniversary night special. Their cheesecake caramels is amazing. We will definitelybe back again. Read more
Guess we disagree with the masses on this place. I say skip the meal here, eat your Italian dinner at Tuscan Tavern & Grill and... come here after for the salted caramel cheesecake, which was out of this world. Everyone talks about the lake view, but reallycould not see it. We sat in the patio, which was adorable. The salads were nice starter and I was hopeful. However, theentree's were so disappointing. My husband had the salmon and it was tasteless - no sear and it smelled in my opinion. I hadthe red sauce with the sausages. The sauce tasted like it came straight out of a can and was really thick and really lousy. The sausage had a strange taste to it in my opinion. The waitstaff was nice. The highlight was the salted caramel dessert -which was truly amazing. And, the restaurant gave it to us for free since our dinners took so long. I thought that was reallyclassy. But, overall it is about the meal. We had two nights there and wanted a great dinner each night and really feel likewe wasted this opportunity. We had lunch at Tuscan the next day and it was like 10 times better! Read more
We hosted our wedding rehearsal dinner here and it was a wonderful experience. The food was great, and each course was served in... a timely manner. The servers and bartender were friendly and attentive, and Sara was responsive and easy to work with during theplanning process. It was all very reasonably priced as well - could not have asked for a better experience! Thank you, Sara andteam! Read more