Reviews for Captain George's Seafood Restaurant in Williamsburg, VA

We went as a party of 6 on a Sunday at noon, was seated immediately. 4 had buffet 2 ordered from the menu. I ordered a steak... from the menu it was delicious, seasoned perfectly. Prices are a bit up there but it was worth every penny. Service wasgreat...6 or more gratuity added... understand that. I will definitely be back. Read more

Very pleasant experience all the way around and the food is not the only star here. The restaurant was very cool in how it was... decorated. From the flowers and the landscaping out front, to the theming inside, it set the scene up to a great meal all theway around. Started with crab legs and they were awesome. Then moved on to some fried scallops and oysters, She-crab soup,Oysters Rockefeller, mussels, two sizes of clams, and other wonderful things and nothing disappointed! I am glad I saved roomfor dessert because everything was great. They even had Baklava and Flan! The food was awesome but the decor and the greatservice made for a very nice experience overall. Thank you! Read more

Pretty dang pleased. Haven't been to a Capt George's in over ten years. This experience blew my last away. From Zac S high... quality on the ball service to seafood to my options. Desert was even fantastic. The variety is just nuts. Their kielbasa andrice and brisket were both to die for. My family LOVED their crab and shrimp. We will be back. Keep up the good work. Read more

Well it was worth the $50 a person with 3 bars of food and friendly service. There is plenty to eat and enjoy. From salad to... pasta, fish crab legs steak veggies and more. The desert bar was also amazing good. You get a complementary coffee with yourdesert. So stop on by with a credit card and eat some leg. Read more

We tried the Captain?s Feast for 1 and the basket of fried oysters. Their seasoning was just right. It wasn?t too spicy or... overpowering. I would have given them 5 stars except for the fact that our feast was supposed to have crawfish in it and therewas none. It just would have been nice for them to let us know if they did not have any. The curbside delivery was convenient.The very nice waitress came out twice, first to take our payment, then to bring our food. Great place. We?ll be back. Read more

We had 4 buses of 5th graders and chaperones. They were very accommodating and friendly. We had an Amazing dinner. The manager... on duty even took the time to show some of our students and parents with allergies the buffet prior to us eating. All the waiterstaff were efficient and kind. There was plenty of food options. We will definitely be back!! A++ Read more

Recently had lunch here for the first time. I mostly stuck to the sea food. I?d say the food quality was what you?d expect at a... buffet, well maybe a bit better. Not great, not bad. The highlight was definitely the crab legs, which were really good.Unfortunately, I wasn?t a fan of the desserts, almost all of the deserts tasted very artificial. Service really was excellent,the wait staff was very friendly and attentive. Overall, I enjoyed my experience. Read more

The crab imperial and the seafood casserole were pretty good. And for dessert, the bread pudding and the banana pudding were... pretty good. The pork ribs were horrible. Everything else I tried was meh. The sliced beef was very tough. The fried oysterswere small and dry. The tiny scallops were not tender and rubbery. The mashed potatoes and gravy were average. All in all forthe price of 50 bucks per person, this was a total let down. My wife did say that the bathroom was very clean and nice. Ourwaitress was always there with an extra drink before we could finish. Excellent service. Read more