Reviews for Mark's Pizzeria in Williamson, NY
Absolutely the worst pizza I have ever received. I usually order from the Webster location, but thought I would give the... Williamson location a try. Pizza arrived cold and very greasy. Somehow even found a way to make a pizza with just spinach andmushrooms greasy. Both pizzas were way over cooked. Was like eating rubber. Very disappointed. Read more
I HATE Mark's! Was only there because my kids eat one style pizza from there and our favorite pizza place was closed. Go to the... Pizza Stop in Pultneyville! Love the pizza, people and atmosphere. Read more
Ordered boneless wings . Was told there would be a wait . 25 minutes later got handed traditional wings. Figured it wasn't... worth the hassle to get them swapped out since my lunch break was almost over , and they tasted mediocre at best. Staff wasnice enough , and apologetic for the wait . They just got the order wrong and it wasn't good. Wouldn't recommend this location. Read more
There calzones are to die for, we live 1 half hours away and Def would drive just for here. We happened to be passing by and ya,... just great staff and food. So nice it's rare these days to find a place that makes you feel not.kust important but family thankyou guys Read more
DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!!! Over the past few months I've given this location a few tries. Every couple months we say, " hey... lets give Marks another shot" we're always disappointed. The last 3 orders they just "forget" pizzas, like an entire pizza justnot there. Yesterday I felt like a fat lazy american and decided to order a pizza. Unfortunately couldn't get it from PizzaStop (which I highly recommend) so I decided to order from Marks, got a couple pizzas and and order of wings. They brought onepizza and the side, wings were something you'd see come from a pizza hut buffet after sitting for 12 hrs. I called the store,they said they'd bring the pizza back out and just never did. There are plenty of other quality pizza joints around Williamson,do not give this place anymore business. Read more
Returned to one of my favorite pizza places on a return trip to see family and the pizza was amazing. I know they can be hit or... miss and thankfully this visit was a hit. Ordered just a classic pepperoni pizza ???? and mom said it was the best she's had ina long time. When it was all said and done I polished off 2/3 of a large pizza. Bad thing to do right before a flight back toFlorida Read more
Williamson location consistently burns their pizza. Even when requesting it ?lightly baked?, it?s still made as shown below. ... How you serve food to a customer made like this is disgraceful. Read more
Best place for slices in the fly. Always a good stock of cheese and pepperoni ready to wrap for flight.