Reviews for Gelateria Dei Coltelli in Williston Park, NY
Nice place to go for dessert. Great quality and selection of gelato. More flavor than ice cream. Great service too. Can't... wait until the new location opens Read more
Phenomenal gelato! The people behind the counter are very friendly and patient. My family has bought several pints and have... tried a variety of flavors. My favorites are the mango, hazelnut, and stracciatella. My family is obsessed with pistachio. We'vedone two flavors in a pint but recommend pairing flavors that complement each other. Read more
Really delicious and affordable! Got A medium gelato cup with two flavors (dark choco and pistachio!) and two iced hazelnut... lattes for ~$16 ish (the city version of this would have been 20+ eaisly). It was extremely clean inside and the gelato was soogood. Our lattes tasted strong, fresh, and delicious. Can't wait to swing by again! Read more
Had a fixing for gelato, so we drove all the way out here because it seemed popular. And popular it was!! The line literally... went out the door, and the business seemed to be held in high regard. The staff is super sweet and accommodating, and worry not,for the line moves rather quickly. Some flavors were already sold out when we got there (a testament to how good their gelatois) so I settled for Panna cotta and straciatella! Super creamy and delicious, but next time I?ll settle for one scoop as twowere enormous enough and I was struggling to finish. Great place! Read more
In my experience this place has the creamiest Gelato. I got pistachio and mango flavors together and the combination was a smash... hit for me. Definitely coming back. Read more
Amazing! This is the best Gelato I've ever had and I happened to have their vegan version since double chocolate chip is my... favorite! I live around an hour and a half away and I will 100% be returning here! Read more
This place is the bees knees for gelato and just satisfying those sweet cravings in general. I've been 2 times in the last week... and will be making plenty more visits. I order a large which allows you 3 scoops at $6.99, which is fantastic! Their pistachiogelato was killer, absolutely delicious, I just wanted to run off into the sunset with the whole tub :D the only think that willmake it better is more chunkier pieces of pistachio. The bacio chocolate is a solid choice for chocolate lovers, not overlysweet but still decadent. The peanut butter was good but could do without the chocolate brownie pieces, I think they were fudge?It was too sweet. The hazelnut was great too, but that pistachio...... :D They also have vegan and non-dairy options which Ilove to see. I'm eyeing the coconut for my next visit ^^ The ladies there are very polite and they've got good covid precautionsin place. Go out of your way for this place, you won't regret it ;) Read more
Perfect texture- creamy, not too thick, not melting immediately, held its shape. I got a scoop each of dark chocolate and mint... chocolate chip. Neither flavor overpowered the other. One of, if not the best, Gelato I've ever had. The texture, consistencyand flavor were everything I hoped it would be. Highly recommend. Read more