Reviews for Portland Pie Company in Windham, ME
So I had very high expectations for the Portland Pie Company. My friends said it is a must stop when coming home from Maine. 1... pie and 2 beers later, I would say it was better than average, but not out-of this world 5 star. I would go back again to trydifferent varieties of pizzas. Read more
Probably best steak bomb I?ve had in a while. Fresh ingredients, delicious melted cheese and mushrooms. Mouth watering. So as... the girl running the bar. Absolute sweetheart and a beauty. Too bad I?m overly realistic and not local. You see, 2 hours drivewouldn?t make out relationship easy. But she?s the girl to buy flowers and bake peanut butter cookies for. Read more
Ordered medium cheese pizza. When we opened the box there was a big puddle of grease on the pizza. I know, most likely from... the cheese. We took pizza back into restaurant and, rather than apologize and show some customer service, they said they couldcook another pizza with less cheese. We declined that offer and kept the pizza. I have eaten many cheese pizzas and never hadone that looked like this. Will not be ordering from here again. Read more
We go every Friday in the summer. The staff are very nice they act like they are glad to see you. Pizza good. Also have... alcohol free beer! Read more
We ordered two pizzas on the menu, but both were lacking in the indredients listed on the specialty pizza description. Ours was... supposed to have goat cheese (there was barely a smattering of it on the pie) and our son's was a meat pizza that had such asmall amount of sausage that it was also barely noticeable. Both pies had soggy crust escept for the very edges of the pies. They said it would take 90 minutes before we could pick it up, so having to wait that long and then it didn't even have all theingredients on it! When I arrived it seemed like it had come out of the oven a while ago. Not worth the $40 we paid for two14" pizzas. Disappointing. Read more
Every pizza place I go to I eat the Margarita Pizza as the benchmark. I ordered the beer crust which is their standard. I have... to say it was close to being one of the best pizzas I've ever had but the sauce was so sweet that I really didn't enjoy it thatmuch it's a personal preference of mine not to have sweet but for me it kind of ruined what I thought might have been one of thebetter pizzas Read more
Nice gluten free crust,, you wouldn't even know if they didn't tell you.. Yes,, it's a tad pricey,, but it's good pizza.
First time experience at the Windham, Maine location (conveniently located off of Eoute 302). Super impressed with the variety... of pie available. Our waitress was super friendly, checked in at the appropriate times, and overall did an amazing job. (Shehad a few other tables she was working with, and she was just as friendly and "on the spot" with them too). The baked potatofries were amazing (perfect amount of melty cheese). The hard part was deciding what pie to order ???? So we tried theBradbury Mountain for the older kids and the adults and a half cheese half pepperoni for the little kids. Ingredients wereevenly dispersed. Twas amazing. We'll be back for sure! Thank you for a great Friday night family dine in experience! Read more