Reviews for Aurelio's Pizza Wheaton / Winfield IL in Winfield, IL

Good home made pizza spot. Enjoyed it. A little empty every time I go there but the service is good.

Man it was a hell of a night for pizza places I?ll never overlook this place again 5 star service all the way around we showed... up 20 min before kitchen closed no complaint had excellent appetizers and pizza on table fast excellent customer service allaround amazing food and experience would recommend to anyone and I?m absolutely making this my stop for pizza thank you mike forthe excellent service Read more

I Rarely Give A Five Star. The Atmosphere Was Nice ????. The Pizza Was Good, But NOT The Best I Have Had. Maybe, Someday I Will... Be Back & Able to Order Something Else. Your Menu Looks Delicious ????. Read more

I received a partially incorrect order on a very busy night and the take-out host as well as the manager helped to make it... right. They remade my order for me and refunded the price of the item that was messed up. I will be back to this Aurelio?sagain. Read more

I have been here many times and have always had a great experience. Love, love, love their pizza?eat in and carry out! The... restaurant has a good selection of beer and wine and a beautiful bar area. Service is always over and above. The salad portionsare generous and they have a nice variety of food, besides their amazing pizza. When the weather is warmer, they have a cozyoutdoor seating area. It?s very clean and a nice, convenient neighborhood restaurant! Read more

I originally visited about a month ago and ordered a stuffed pizza, and when I got home I realized that it was very undercooked.... I discussed the situation with the manager of the restaurant the next day and they offered to remake the pizza for my nextvisit. Today I called and arranged for the replacement stuffed pizza. It was a noticeable improvement from the first pizza butsomething just doesn't seem right to me, compared to other pizza places I've tried with stuffed pizza, it's like the cheese iswarm but not melted (I tried to capture it in a picture but I'm not sure that it translates well. Imagine of you will a pile ofcheese that you left out in the hot sun, its warm but only some melted some just warm) I realize that a stuffed pizza isprobably more challenging than a regular pizza but perhaps it would be best to remove it from the menu if the kitchen can'tfigure out how to melt cheese. I ultimately decided to go with a middle of the road three star rating because the pizza was OKbut not great. I was also disappointed that my pizza wasn't ready at the scheduled time even though I ordered it an hour twentyminutes before I wanted to pick it up. The saving grace was the associate at the pickup register was super friendly and kind.During my 10 minute wait I was able to observe them interacting with several customers and providing an amazing experience. Ithink I'll give them another shot but I'm definitely going to try a classic pizza instead of a stuffed. Read more

I have now ordered from this location twice. The first time I got the entirely wrong pizza, and they promptly sent out a new... pizza. I figured I'd give it another shot, but now they sent me the most burnt pizza I've ever eaten. How they let this even goout the door is beyond me, and they should really be embarrassed by this. I definitely will not be ordering from this locationagain. Read more

Only open 4 days. New staff and the they made mistakes with the orders. The owners went out of their way to fix any issues.... Pizza was ok. They need to get pizza towers because when they placed a large pizza on the table, they left no room for plates ordrinks. Lots of room for team parties and the decor was pleasing. We will give them another try after the have worked out ofsome of the kinks. Read more