Reviews for NY Bagel Deli and Pizza in Winter Garden, FL
A true NY deli that had a sweet lunch special and THE BEST CANNOLIS I have EVER had. The texture and cream was crafted with such... expertise and excellence that it melted in your mouth, and the chocolate chips were the perfect consistency to compliment. 1000%get a cannoli from here!!! Read more
Extraordinary experience! The closest NY Style Pizza to the real N.Y. pizza! I only had two slices but let me tell you, I wish I... had a whole pie! For take out it was the key lime cheesecake that caught my eye. The slices are pretty big and sooo tasty too.Last time I had Key lime that tasted this good was in Key Largo, imagine that! The entire little village is enchanting. Thetrees are wrapped with white Xmas lights and the night experience is so incredibly charming?even under the rain! So folks, allI can say about my experience is, please take a ride as soon as you can, because you too will be enamored with the lights,sounds and the aroma of West Plant Street! Enjoy! Read more
Wow!! What a great combination of NY style foods... Gourmet Bagels, Greaaaaat pizza and sweets galore including hand dipped ice... cream!! Friendly staff tops off the whole experience!! Read more
Bagels are good Cheese cake and cupcakes should be PULLED off the shelves! Old cupcakes! Could NOT even stick a plastic knife... on the cupcake. Took forever to get lox bagel, will Not be returning. Read more
This place stays busy all day. They have a great selection of bagels, sandwiches, and pizza. I was surprised when I saw the... Italian Ice and ice cream, you can't go wrong. Spacious inside with plenty of seating inside and out. Super friendly and helpfulstaff, made me feel at home. Highly recommend! Read more
Best pizza in Winter Garden! I only wish they stayed open later. Can?t wait to try the bagels next. The review photos look... delicious. Read more
I'm guessing that they bring in the WOH-tah from New Yawhk, because their bagels taste pretty authentic! I should know - born... and raised in the NY metro area. I was kinda disappointed with the iced coffee, although the bagels and cheesecake weretop-notch. Nice location too, especially when the weather cooperates. Read more
Stopped in at NY Bagel while on Plant Street in Winter Garden. It wasn't meal time but I was intrigued that they had house made... bialys, bagels and pizza. Yum. I brought home some bialys to try as we normally have to go to Boynton Beach to get excellentbialys. This bialy is the real deal. Perfect. Cut in half toasted with butter. The perfect crunch and chew. Yum. Nice peoplefrom Queens too. When I come back for the bagels and pizza, I'm sure I'll change their rating to a 5 star. Read more