Reviews for My Sisters Pizza in Winthrop, ME
Best meatball sub I've ever had! Beautifully decorated, cozy dining area and excellent service.
My order was mis heard when I called it in. I called back after I picked up my order and we realized that the order was... misheard, they put a rush on making my order correct and wouldn't let me pay the difference. Great customer service! Read more
Service excellent and food very good sauce price was very fair Pizza super
Before you get blindsided by the price increase make sure you ask. Was expecting to pay around $25 according to the prices I saw... online for a 14? pepperoni pizza and a 4 piece chicken tender and fries box. Checking out it was $37.. that was the first issue.Upon getting home and opening the food the fries were burnt and flavorless and almost cold despite living 2 minutes away and thepizza dough was still raw. I do not recommend this place at all. The one star given is being generous. Read more
I have eaten to many numerous types of dishes and both hot and cold sandwiches from My Sister?s Pizza to even list everything.... However?I will say I have never had a bad experience with the food or the waitress/wait staff. I find the service phenomenalfrom start to finish each and every time. The food is always on time and prepared to perfection. I know when I?m told that it?sa 50 minute wait?there?s a good damn reason?they are very busy, so place your orders according to the time you like having yourlunch or dinner. Don?t wait and call when your famished and be upset because you have to wait. Anything good is worth waitingfor. Enjoy the delicious food that the kitchen staff works so preciously on to appease everyone?s appetite. Read more
They had very good service along with decent food. While I did not eat the food as it was not gluten free, my family said it was... great. The lady at the front was very nice and even gave us a large bag of chips for free. According to my family, the saladhere is better than the nearby TJ?s pizza, but they like the cheese flavor at TJ?s more. The food seemed to be great quality,and very fresh for the price. Read more
Awesome pizza, large selection of favorite meals like chef salad and pasta. Easily accommodate a group of 10 at the 2 large... dining tables. 5 private booths are perfect for a family meal or a business meeting. The zen atmosphere is welcoming and thestaff is very friendly. Read more
The food was good, the service was very friendly, the atmosphere was so pretty all decorated for Christmas.