Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Woodbury, NY

This place has a delicious menu .we had the Woodbury restaurant catering our party everything from the meatball’s to the... pizza was hot and awesome ! The manager Phil really takes pride in this establishment. 5stars! Read more

The pizza was good, and the drinks were great. Would recommend for a family dinner event for kids and just going with friends .

Amazing food and service! We were visiting from FL and the server brought us wings to try, these are hands down the best wings... I’ve had in my life!! Cooked to perfection, full of flavor, just the best! Then we got our pizza and it was just as fresh andamazing! If we ever come back to NY we will definitely be making a special stop to this location! Read more

Very friendly staff very helpful and will make you custom pizzas to fit your taste buds. Bit on the pricey side but you do... definitely get what you pay for. They have a full bar and place to sit for lunch and dates. So far everything I had was verywell seasoned be down to try everything worth it!! Read more

A frequent flyer at this best of Anthony's Pizza. The food is always good but me and my crew are hoping for a return to more... abundant pre pandemic selections! Drink specials are appreciated as are the rewards program. TV's and piped in tunes are good.Love the help! Great parking with bustling takeout! Read more

Overall was a good dinner at an affordable price. Large pizza with 6 garlic knots for around $30, can’t beat that. The only... reason this is not a 5 star review is because of the garlic roles being too oily. On to-go orders they arrive in a box sittingin about 1/4” of oil. Other than that though it was good. Read more

After reading postive reviews online. Today I went to have lunch. Restaurant is conveniently located on west bound Jericho... turnpike. Parking is not a problem. I went inside and warmly welcomed by host. After reviewing the menu I placed the take outorder.they have big bar with nice collection of liquors. Lots of table to dine in.due to coronavirus pandemic, all the staffwearing masks, even chefs wearing too. So, this made me more comfortable to have the food. Charcoaled wings with carmalisiedonions taste so good. Absolutely delicious ????. Pepperoni and bacon was awesome. I ordered another pie with peppers, onions,hit peppers totally mouthwatering. You can smell and taste the Charcoaled flavor. Definitely will go back. Read more

I remember wanting to go here before the lockdowns and was so relieved to see Anthony's stayed afloat! The pizza is delicious,... light, crisp, and authentic. Our server was super nice and made us feel welcome. Will definitely become regulars here ???? Read more