Reviews for Catskill Mountain Pizza Co in Woodstock, NY
I've been ordering here, or trying to, for 3 years now. Not anymore. Pizza is mediocre. Often don't have... ingredients...ham...meatballs etc. Orders are wrong more than you"d expect. Cash only. But the absolute worst thing is justtrying to place an order. Try to call on a weeknight or anytime on a weekend and you will get immediately put on hold for 30+minutes or until you hang up... Which seems to be what the staff wants. Go in and watch the clown show of untrained, unmotivatedworkers do their best to not help you. I tried. I really did. Wanted to support a local business and all that. But it's ahorrible, insulting experience. I'm done. Read more
All I can say is if you're on the fence, just try it out. Not sure where the ingredients are sourced from, but I'd love to know... because you can taste the quality. I've had the portobello "burger", which was a smash hit for me. I've also had their sausagepie, which was exquisite. Just remember: cash only! Read more
Standard fare, reliably good pizzas. I usually order large sausage pizzas, and they are good/satisfying. Only cash... accepted. Phone ordering spotty and hard at times. Read more
We ordered our meal to go and it took about 20 minutes on a not-too-busy Thursday night. Both The Godfather and Margherita were... delicious. Appreciated the loads of basil on the marg. The sauce is tangy and a bit sweet; crusts quite thin, which we liked.The fried calamari was crunchy and well seasoned too! Read more
Omg, their pizza was surprisingly delicious. We took a day trip to the Catskills & stopped there for a bite. Everyone wanted... pizza but me. I'm A BIG pizza lover, & thought to myself this is not going to be good. To my surprise it was up there withthe top pizza makers. I had a eggplant pizza. The price was pretty reasonable as well. Read more
Seriously one of the best pizza places in all of NY! The specialty pizzas are absolutely to die for! Every single one is... incredibly delicious. Try them all! I think my favorite, is the Bonanza pizza! See included picture. The single plain slices arextra large and two is a whole meal, making it in my opinion the best value lunch in town. They're always busy so you might haveto wait on hold if you call in but 100% worth the wait. They also have a nice small bar and dining room in the back. Lots ofcraft beers to choose from. If you're in Woodstock don't pass this place up! Read more
Cute place on the main drag with friendly staff and a yummy pie. We had an order to go and sat outside in their seating area. It... was pleasantly warm sitting in the sun as we munched. The pizza was the perfect amount of cheesy and crispy! Great lunch! Quickservice and our pup liked it too! Read more
The spa chicken burger was delicious! I went back two days later and tried the portobello mushroom burger and that was equally... delicious! Fast service and friendly staff Everything looks good Read more