Reviews for The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Old Worthington in Worthington, OH

Food was great. I had the lobster bisque and the signature dish....fish and chips. I was sitting at the bar and overheard a... woman place a to go order. She asked for the fish and chips to be "Eddie style"(I think????). I asked what that meant and thebartender explained its a spicy/blackened batter. It was outstanding!! Perfectly seasoned, breaded and fried. So good. The chipswere good, especially w a healthy shake of malt vinegar and some salt. The Cole slaw was good as well. Bartender was superfriendly, actually the whole vibe and atmosphere was very friendly. Everything I want in a neighborhood pub.???? Read more

1st time after 4 years in Cbus. The "best in the city" fish and chips were below average. The fish itself was good, not greasy,... but the breading was lackluster with no flavor or crispiness. The "chips" were terrible, tasted like bad store bought frozenfries, and several were under cooked. Wings were dry and lacking flavor. Fish tacos would have been much better without salsatopping, again the fish itself was good. Server did the bare minimum. Overall can't recommend based on this experience. Read more

This was the first time I was at the location in Worthington. It was more like a bat than the others, which I found interesting.... I went because I was craving their fish and chips. Only they can stop that craving. They never disappoint. Read more

First time there in the evening. The coke, tea and water were flat and had little taste. Did not seem fresh at all. The FO... soup was great. The fish and chip were but as crispy as usual during the lunch crowd. I drive from Dublin to go there. I guesswe are back to the Dublin Tavern where the drinks and food is consistent. Read more

I popped in for dinner with the friend about 7:00 p.m. Saturday night. There are lots of tables and we're not overly busy for... food service. Usually I'm inclined to get their fish and chips, which is absolutely stunning. This time I went with anotherfavorite, they're all you can eat soup and salad. Always get their standard salad, but you can also get a Caesar or a spinachsalad. And they have some of the best french onion soup around. I also like their clam chowder, New England style. The clams arealways nicely tender. Service was good as usual. Read more

Was scheduled to work a few miles from this location, perfect place to stop before starting at customer?s site. My... brother-in-law recommended the Worthington location and a coworker had been to the same one and gave a good recommendation aswell. The fish and chips (Eddie style) was absolutely awesome! Next time will try something else? maybe. Great food, greatservice. Read more

Wow, what exciting history to learn about while enjoying the best fish and chips in the Columbus region. The staff team is... super friendly and eager to please the hungry patrons whether it's great food selections or adult beverages. The establishmentis very clean and well organized with pleasant decor throughout. I can't wait to return soon and enjoy another great selectionfrom their diverse menu selections. Read more

Amazing! Love the food and staff. The fish and chips are really good. We had an order of fish and chips, double stack cheese... burger with fries, 2 small caesar salads, coke and a tall cranberry/vodka to drink for $41 I would definitely go back. Read more