Reviews for American Sandwich Co. in Wyalusing, PA
Nice, clean restaurant. Waitress was very pleasant, and attentive. Food was excellent as always. The best Cuban and cheesesteak... sandwhichs. A must stop on our annual fishing trip. Read more
Excellent sandwiches!!! Moved to the area recently and tried their takeout for lunch. I would give a 5 but my sandwich was... incorrect, ordered a cuban and received turkey instead of ham - still tasty. Highly recommend the Rachel on rye, slaw anddressing are amazing. Toasted the bread, big portions. The fries are also great and saw some desserts that are on my list fornext time. Read more
Disappointing. Thought it would be a great place to stop with all the great reviews. The decor of the restaurant was really... nice. It was clean from what I could tell. I didn't appreciate getting a bottled water rather than tap. And the sandwich wasless than stellar so I didn't even eat it. I ordered the roasted vegetables. Not worth it. Definitely will not be back. I wouldnot recommend. Read more
Might have been good if they were open like the sign said? Was looking forward to eating here on our trip.
I ordered some take out from this restaurant and it was great. Service was fast and they had a vast array of baked goods and... sides to go. Read more
The place is adorable and the food was amazing. I got the main street and it was so good. My husband got the cheesesteak and... loved it. We loved the rolls and homemade blue cheese in particular. The desserts looked amazing but we didn't get any, nexttime for sure. In non pandemic times it looks like a great place to hang out. Read more
A beautifully redone restaurant. Lovely environment. My grandma got the Reuben sandwich and I got the strawberry cucumber... poppyseed salad. Both were absolutely amazing and flavorful. We look forward to eating here again! Read more
Went up to the counter, was given menus and told to have a seat, someone would be right over to take our order. Sat at the table... for 18 minutes and still no one came. Only one other table in the whole place and they were already served. We walked out. Read more