Reviews for A and S Italian Market of Wyckoff in Wyckoff, NJ

We ordered a 7 foot sub for a party for about 30 adults and 20 kids. Sooooooo much food!! It was 3 large platters of amazing... portion sliced sandwiches. Most was the Italian sub and the rest eggplant sub. Everyone loved both, I was surprised how popularthe eggplant was. We did have a whole platter left over, we ordered way too much but better to have extra than not enough.Everyone gave compliments on the food and most plates were empty when cleaning up. We will definitely order another catered subfor our next party. Read more

Great local Italian deli!

Solid Italian deli on par with those I’m used to on Arthur Ave. food is always fresh, great mozzarella and lots of cheese... selections, wide variety of prepared foods, and always essential Italian imports available. Great service as well. Read more

I was visiting family and stopped by to bring all the fixings to my cousins house. The food was Amazing, and very fresh to... order. Staff was very friendly. Great job ! Read more

Always delicious and incredible value! This sandwich could feed a small family and is loaded into an amazing seeded roll! I... always end up buying a bunch of other goodies to bring home for later. You won't be disappointed, give them a try! Read more

This is the real deal. I know I am just echoing what a lot of other people are saying, but you will pay about ten percent more... here, and get about 100 percent better quality and taste. Real, fresh made mozzarella, real italian made, aged cold cuts, justoverall, it is like comparing a steak to a mcdonald's hamburger. Read more

Best short ribs. I don’t even make them anymore because we love these so much ... and I used to make great short ribs ...... these are fabulous. They have really high quality food and great service. Try the garlic bread too! : ) Read more

Best Italian deli around. They have everything you want. Italian imported goods aged meat great cold cuts premade foods that... will blow your mind. Prices are a bit high but this isnt atop and shop. Your are getting amazing foods. I come here all thetime for specialty items or just a killer prosciutto roasted peppers fresh mozzarella on bread. Looking forward to lunch rightnow. I cant wait. Staff is all business but very helpful. And get there early cause the lines will back up and you startwanting to buy everything in the place. Read more