Reviews for Pizza Love in Wyckoff, NJ
Love this place I am considered a regular here. The food is excellent. Very nice portions and taste is authentic. Have been here... during lunch time alone sometimes with friends. I recommend coming here you won't be sorry. Read more
Overpriced, rude, and not very smart. Ordered via Uber eats. No option for special instruction. Wanted simple substitute of... feta for blue cheese for dietary purposes. Called the restaurant and they put me on hold twice and then told me the salad wasalready made and chastised me for not calling sooner and for not calling Uber eats instead??! Extremely rude and not very bright- bad combination. So much for the “love”. Overpriced rude pizzeria. Read more
Nice family place, friendly staff great food prices reasonable highly recommend this place
Every time we have a large gathering, we order catering from pizza love and it is delicious every time. The order is always... right, the delivery is right on time, and they are always accommodating of any requests we have. Highly recommend. In photo:Pizza, garlic bread, calamari, boneless wings, eggplant parm, chicken parm, penne vodka and sautéed mixed vegetables! Read more
Third time I ordered and it’s so wrong. Amazing how you use grubhub to accept your orders and screw it up every time. I used... to say “the best in town”! When I called to speak with someone the gal didn’t know what to do. I told her I called thestore and got grubhub who 3x screwed up the order. Flustered I got the manager Jesse who couldn’t hear my phone call. I am inthe pizza love system and used to delight in picking up my irders.I am DO N E! Pear salad no cheese or walnuts??? Weird! Read more
Their slices are HUGE. Their pizza is good. 4 stars because we went there and ordered 2 BBQ chicken slices and ate them in the... car. They were really good!! Then we ordered a BBQ chicken pie a few weeks later and ate it at home and the bottom was soggy andthicker than it had been the last time we went. Too much dough. I’ll give them another shot though and only order a slice nexttime. Read more
A very good slice of Pizza at Pizza Love. The place was very clean and the staff was very nice and provided great service. The... Pizza Sauce speaks to you first at Pizza Love followed by a very good crust. The cheese was very chewy, but the sauce and crustmade up for it. This is an above average slice and we shall see where they end up in the Bergen County Rankings on the PizzaHunters App. Read more
This fast casual pizza place is certainly not fast but very casual. Food is decent but they will mess up your order somehow.... Literally EVERY time we have ordered from this place they have messed It up. Either poorly trained or managed, either way thiswas the last time we’ll be ordering here. Tons of families in wyckoff share the same sentiment and have stopped ordering fromhere - we’re done Read more