Reviews for Pizzeria Mandara in Wyckoff, NJ
The service was excellent as was the food. Great portions. Our waiter was attentive without being a nuisance. We had a 4:30... reservation and by the time we left around 6:30, the place was packed. Reservations are strongly recommended. Read more
This was an amazing slice of pizza! It tasted so fresh as well! Homemade fresh mozzarella, crushed san marzano tomatoes, basil,... fresh garlic, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil. The fresh ingredients tasted so much better than regular pizza! 10/10Would most definitely recommend! Read more
First of all woman who answered the phone said I could order for a specific time of pickup so I asked for 1 hour, 4:45 and my... husband got there 20 minutes early and it was already waiting for him... It has absolutely no flavor whatsoever, potatoes werenever seasoned and neither were the onions the bottom of the crust is soggy and dry on top; it tastes like cardboard...Sodisappointed! Read more
In a area with 5 Italian restaurants within walking distance of each other, Pizzeria Mandara holds its ground well. Offering... both an amazing pizza front and a fantastic atmosphere for a family dinner. Read more
Normally one of my favorite places to eat but not today..Had lasagna asked for light on the sauce.It was swimming in sauce and... the piece of lasagna was all broken up and some of the noodles were crunchy.Had to stop eating due to bad heartburn. Should haveordered my favorite chicken dish. Very disappointed .walking out hungry.wait staff did not ask how it was or notice I did noteat it or want to take it home. Read more
Never disappointed !! From the rice balls to the baked clams to the pizza to the veal or sausage with pasta enjoy it very much.... Coconut cake is awesome ! Not my favorite “red” sauce but that’s just me/ everyone we have taken loves it. Read more
Charged my poor mom 45 dollars for 1 meal posing as vodka cream sauce and another Pomordini that looked like it tasted.... RAGU... JAR SAUCE with slimy onions. I had to post a picture of this food joke that looks like macaroni and butter (Vodka cream saucedisguising as a 25$ dish) Not to mention the obvious frozen chicken that came from a Restaurant Depot wholesale bag. I hear thatthe owners are from Italy. How is this possible when these dishes look like an acceptable meal in a rural Kansas town? Shame.Contact me ASAP if you guys have any decency. This is a culinary disgrace. Read more
We are new to the neighborhood and found this place to be really good. Everything about it was good. We shared a Nonna pizza... which was fantastic. Definitely going back as there are some super delishious items on the menu. Read more