Reviews for Eagles Nest Restaurant & Event Venue in York, PA

One of the best meals Ive had in a while. Everyone at the table thoroughly enjoyed the food and great service. Chris was a very... pleasant, funny, knowledgeable and professional waiter. I had prime rib, wife had the crab cake. Both were amazing, as well asthe sides and lamb chop app. Desert knocked it out of the park!!! Really looking forward to our return. Read more

Everything was really good here-from the salad, rolls, harborside salmon, and my partner's fisherman risotto! Definitely want to... go back and try more of the menu. It is on the pricey side though, so it feels like a place for special occasions. Read more

This restaurant is amazing! I called to ask if I could propose to my fiance there. I was introduced to Eli the manager who... greeted me with warmth and sincere enthusiasm. He displayed exceptional attention to detail and offered insight that wasinstrumental. He helped me practice and set up the proposal and using creativity and discretion graciously took us through anight we will forever remember. The food was phenomenal, the ambience was perfect, service impeccable, the view spectacular. Eagle's Nest will always be a special place for Jessica thanks to Eli, Alex our waitress, and all of the amazing staff at thisfine eatery. Thank God for Eagle's Nest. Read more

There's a nice patio out back to enjoy warm weather. I ordered the 10 oz filet and added a crabcake. Both were delicious. The... filet was like melting butter in my mouth. I also had the crab with spinach dip. It was creamy and cheesy. They have nice viewsfrom upstairs. Read more

My amazing boyfriend wanted to take me somewhere nice to eat and wouldn’t tell me where! He took me to Eagles nest which is... one of the nicest restaurants I have ever been too. The view as well as they have a very nice deck, it was a bit too hot andhumid to want to sit outside. We were sat near the window with a beautiful view. Their menu had a lot of great soundingchoices. Our server Chris was very attentive, friendly and informative. We were both very pleased with the service we received!We got the crab dip appetizer and it is the best crab dip I’ve ever had!! Their food came out fast and to perfection! I gotthe Delmonico steak and Christian got the prime rib. Both came out cooked perfectly. I hope to come back again sometime in thenear future! Read more

One of the best restaurants in York County. Very well executed, fresh food. Good service. I highly recommend for a quality... meal. Edit 5/31: I still agree with my original review that this is a top restaurant in York, but it second experience wasn'tas impressive as the first. We strayed from seafood and a couple of us got some beef dishes. In my opinion, they execute seafoodextremely well, their execution of the beef dishes was mediocre. My recommendation: you can't go wrong with any of the seafooddishes we've tried. The beef dishes (prime rib, filet, etc.), although clearly high quality ingredients, we're not executed aswell as they could have been. Read more

Had an amazing dinner! Best Prime Rib in York County! Chris our server was very personable, friendly, knowledgeable, and quick... at task!!! He did a super job for us he even made me some of his very own recipe of horseradish dip for my prime rib….yummy! My husband and I enjoyed the beautiful view inside and outside from the upper level of the restaurant! We had a very niceevening! Took dessert home with me! Read more

Went here with my father. We both got the filet with crab imperial on top. The steaks were cooked perfectly,and the quality of... the meat was well above most restaurants. The desserts were even exceptional as well. I wish I could've gotten a pic of those,but we ate them as soon as we saw them. The only negative thing I had here was the cream of crab soup wasn't very creamy, butmore of a liquid broth with 2 bites of crab meat in it. I'm from MD so I've had tons of cream of crab soups from my state. Nexttime I come back I will try the chili instead. This was a great place, I even bought a gift certificate for a friend. Can't waitto try more items from the menu! Read more