Reviews for Victor's Italian Restaurant in York, PA
My boyfriend and I came here for the first time last night to celebrate our 6 year anniversary. We had McKenzie as our waitress... and she was so nice and knowledgeable of the menu! I got the tortellini and he got the veal Marsala. We got the appetizer of thewhipped feta and every was delicious! Will for sure be back. Worth the money. Read more
I am not sure if something has changed with ownership, or there is a new chef, but we were so disappointed in the food. My... daughter ordered chicken fingers and they arrived almost black. We looked around at other tables where other kids had the samething and they were all also black, so we figured well maybe that's just how they are made, maybe there is something in thebatter that makes them darker. My daughter bit into them and choked on them because they were so burnt and dry. Luckily Iordered airline chicken that tasted just like a piece of broiled chicken with no season. It had no flavor. So I cut it up andgave it to her because she is not a seasoning girl, so she ate that. She said the french fries were good. My husband orderedthe halibut special. It came out like a block and was solid. Typically you're able to cut halibut with your fork he had to usea knife. When his espresso came it was cold, he put the sugar cube in and it didn't even melt. Maybe it was an off night, but Iwould not go back, especially for the prices considering what you get. Read more
Went there to celebrate the end of a good summer. Don't get out to eat much but was glad we picked here. One of the best 3... course meals I have had in a long time. Ashley, our server was very hospitable, and friendly. A very intimate setting for a nicedate night. We will return to check out the Fall Menu for sure. Read more
Very friendly service. Good food. A bit pricey. If you're booking on Open Table app, bar seating means a seat at the actual bar,... not a high top table in the bar area. I'm all for sitting at the bar for a fun, casual experience, but definitely not for a $300Valentine's Day dinner. Luckily they were able to get us a normal table. Read more
Our hearts are still fluttering.. not only because this is restaurant is THE perfect little diamond in the rough. Not just... because the atmosphere and decor are unlike any other spot in Central Pa. Not just because the food was top notch, from thelamb lollipops to the Osso Buco that slid off the bone like a stick of butter on a desert stone.. not for the extensive winemenu, or for the way the his/hers dessert plate lit up our eyes like a first kiss. No. For us, cupid's arrow made it'sdescent into our hearts when the executive chef entered the dining room to greet us. He took the time to describe ourentrees and made it a point to make us feel special. He was AS beautiful as the meals that leaves his kitchen. On thisvalentines day, it wasn't just my heart that was pulsating. Read more
Service was great!! 5 star for service. Food was good and was a 5 star as well... I rated it 4 star because the dessert menu was... just eh as far as choice. Dessert was just sub par at best... I dont suggest getting dessert. Read more
This place absolutely blew my mind. Our waitress was on top of everything without being overly attentive while we were eating,... very polite, and so helpful. She even went over her and other's favorites and explained everything about each item on the menuthat we asked about. They easily have the best scallops that I've ever had. The food was mouth-watering with generous portions.The drink and food menus were sophisticated and had the best selection anywhere in York and it's surrounding areas. This placeis an absolute must have if you're in the area. This place deserves the coveted 7/5 stars. The only place that I've rated thathighly. Read more
The food and drinks were super delicious and our server Gillian was very attentive. She had great recommendations on what we... should get (We got the tortellini and shrimp linguine, both AMAZING). We could not have had a better experience and willdefinitely be coming back! Read more