Reviews for Carmella's Café in Youngstown, OH
Had the most amazing dinner here last week ! Cozy and welcoming restaurant. Definitely give this place a try if you want ... authentic Italian Read more
The food was great. The service was great! They were so accommodating and patient with my husband who has had a stroke and is in... a wheelchair. We will be back! Read more
I've eaten in person there several times and their Italian food is awesome. More recently I've gotten a fish sandwich and fries... which also are great! Read more
Charming Italian restaurant. Salmon is good but the eggplant Parmesan is excellent. My husband got the grouper and crab cake... tonight, he was so happy with it. We really loved our server. He was extremely sweet and was very good with our two littlegirls. He made so many accommodations and was very hands on. Carmela?s is definitely a gem because of the food but their staffis what makes this place next level. Read more
I so want to give them 5 stars, but the last few times we've been there has been disappointing. The Calamari was just plain... mushy. Hubs ordered a Ceasar salad with salmon. Salmon was cooked to perfection, but dressing was more vinegar like, and didn'tcompliment the salad very well. I had a shaved beef sandwich with mozzarella and it was average. Maybe a few more spices orsomething to jazz it up? Chicken here is always tender, and Alfredo is amazing. Stark contrast between lunch and dinner menuand preparation. Would definitely recommend for dinner. Lunch? Not so much. Read more
We were so disappointed with our meals from here! We were expecting some good things! We ordered a 10 oz sirloin steak which... significantly must have gone on a diet before we got it because the onion rings were more plentiful and bigger than the steak!We also ordered a dish called Victoria Chicken. It was listed as two grilled or fried chicken breasts covered with sauce, cheeseand greens. We asked for no greens but what was left was confusing. There was sauce..but it was loaded with red peppers andtomatoes and onions. The coating was soggy and the cheese had all but disappeared. The fries that came with it were mediocre atbest. We got a cup of wedding soup..uh..all it was was spinach stems and 2 shredded pieces of chicken and 2 count them 2meatballs. Amazing...$40+ dollars for horrible food! Read more
This is real Italian! Traditional family recipes and modern twist on classic dishes give variety for your pallet! The stuffed... banana peppers are a summertime favorite!! Staff is on it!! Read more
The food is good and so is the service. Vegetarian options are numerous, but I also love the lasagna. Ample parking.