Reviews for Black Cat Pizzeria in Yulee, FL
First time ordering from you. Two Staff members I spoke to with was very nice and helpful. Gluten-free pizza was okay. Could... have been cooked just a little bit longer. Put it in a pan when I got home to crunch up the bottom, it was great then. I willdefinitely order again and also try a non gluten-free pizza. Read more
August 2022. First time here and we were all pleasantly surprised. Large pizzas are really large, the three of us had half a... pizza left. Very flavorful pizza with good crust too. We\'ve been back one time since for to-go pizza and it was just as good.Would have been 5 stars but an employee was walking around drinking a beer. He may have just got off shift or something, butstill just didn\'t seem quite right. Read more
Pizza is great, but watch out they scam you on the toppings. Thin crust NY Style Pizza with lots of fresh toppings. Pizza is... reasonable priced too. But watch out for a scam on the toppings. If you order a two topping pizza, with 1/2 the pizza with 2toppings, and the other 1/2 with two different toppings, they charge you for a 4 topping pizza. That’s a rip off.\n\nThecounter service and table side delivery is great. Sit down area is large, clean, and has a great vibe. Nice wall art andfunkiness.\n\nStaff is friendly and efficient. Great to finally have a family owned pizza place in Yulee! Read more
I have been waiting to try their pizza since they opened. Glad I have it a try, definitely worth the wait. Large, large pizzas... for a great price. Ordered close to closing and the staff was great. For all the locals definitely give them a try and for allthe tourist worth the trip to pick it up. Read more
Solid pizza and a friendly staff! We had the BBQ pizza. The medium was fairly large and very good. Did have a bit of garlic,... but we liked it. The bread sticks were good, but will probably skip them next time or try a different version. Good place forthe whole family. Read more
This was our second time here and we had a few pizzas, Meat, Supreme and a few beers.\nToppings were plentiful and the beer was... cold. Will return again. Read more
We got the Supreme pizza with the Homie and Baby salads, it was very good. Nice to have a decent pizza on our side of town... again. The staff was helpful and welcoming, while waiting for the pizza we received our salads first quite promptly. Thewaitress was very attentive and kept us in the loop on what was going on as we did have a bit of a wait on the pizza. Read more
I do not leave reviews, but this place is fantastic! Not only is the pizza phenomenal, but the people are amazing! They messed... up my order, which was not a big deal considering it was such a minor mistake. However, they insisted on providing a gift cardfor a free large pizza. Not only did I leave with a larger pizza than I purchased, but I also got another one for free! That isenough to make me a loyal customer! Moving forward, I will not get pizza from anywhere else, even if it means driving to pick itup from Black Cat! Sometimes, mistakes are natural, but their response was excellent! Especially considering I was contentbecause the error was so minor, it was not a big deal! Good luck getting this kind of service anywhere else in today\'ssociety. Did I mention the pizza is fantastic? They do not cut corners on high-quality ingredients! The free pizza gift card wasjust the icing on the cake in making me a forever returning customer! Give your employees a raise because they are providingoutstanding customer service and will bring you more business in the future! I vow never to order Hungry Howies again! I willeven drive to pick my pizza up to give you my business because of your employees and great pizza! Read more