Reviews for New York Prime in Atlanta, GA
Our waiter set the bar very high saying NYP was just like our favorite steakhouse. Cool, let's see (but now we're a little... jaded). Complimentary bubbles from Geno, table breads, Old Fashioned for the table, Stone Crab and Baked Shrimp appetizers,Pittsburgh-style New York Strip & Bone-in Ribeye (perfectly cooked), Southwest Creamed Corn, and Charred Brussel Sprouts wereall impressive in their own way... but not the same as our favorite. Lawrence's service, attention, and patience were a hit! Verdict: We'll go back... one day. Read more
Excellent service and good attention. Every employee showed good hospitality skills. The bar has excellent atmosphere, ideal for... a quick drink, socialize or have a nice meal. The dining room is large with well distributed spaces all along. The goodmaintenance is notable from afar. The food selection is almost as it was curated with delicacy and excellent taste. My steak wasclose to being perfectly cooked, probably some of the best I’ve had in many years. Their service had a couple of minor hiccupsbut mostly due to some miss communication. It was promptly addressed by our most attentive serverJeff. Lastly, their drinks andwine selection was as splendid as the quality of the food. They have complimentary valet but they also validate parking at thenearby lot. $$$$$ Read more
Wow! What a wonderful dining experience. Food AMAZING! Service AMAZING! Ambiance AMAZING! Valet option (complimentary only... requires tip) or parking deck (validated). I cannot believe I've never been here but I'll definitely return soon. Thank youLawrence for helping my bff to have a wonderful bday! Oh.... music was pretty cool as well. Nice variety! Read more
Atlanta's fine dining at its best. From the moment you walk in you realize you are going to have a outstanding experience. The... food was cooked perfectly and prepared just like each of us asked. All of our meats were cooked to our requested temperatures.The shareable sides were good and definitely enough for two people to share. All in all a great restaurant. Read more
Tonight was our Saturday date night and New York Prime didn’t disappoint us!!! The French Martini was awesome and the lobster... ???? ribeye steak and redfish with crab ???? meat was superb!! Thanks to Ennio the manager for his professionalism!!! ???????? Read more
We went there for dinner today. We ordered 32 oz aged steak and 8 oz steak with spinach and broccolini. It was too crowded in... the bar area and we were sitting very close to the bar area. It was noisy. Food is average, it’s not worth the price. Servicewas good. Lighting was too dark. Read more
The restaurant was a very nice environment, however the food taste did not match the pricing. I ordered a Petite New York Strip... medium well (it did not look like a new york strip). It was burnt and I couldn't get past the burnt buttery taste. Sides are notincluded in the pricing beside the meat. Everything has a separate price. However, you do get a lot of food with the sides,enough to share with several people. If you are doing a group outing you have to pay all in 1 check, not separate, they don'ttell you this. Overall I didn't think it was worth the money, and do not plan to return again. But the atmosphere is nice! Read more
Very good experience. The item that totally blew me away was the lamb! The steaks were good.. but this was the best lamb I've... ever had! Service was good.. and fast.. we ate family style so tried a bunch of different items. Read more