Reviews for Mythical Pizza in Berkeley Springs, WV
This place is amazing. From the decor to the staff to the owner. I'm in love with the pizzas! And you HAVE to try the Cryptid... Club Sodas! Pineapple is my favorite so far. They also have a Cryptid gift section, where you can get coffee and hats andt-shirts and do not forget the handmade Plushies! My favorite pizza place. Read more
We pass through B Springs regularly for travel and will be sure to make this a regular spot! Finally tried it and was not... disappointed. Staff is great! Pizza was fantastic. Their custom drinks are great as well. Cool vibes. Goodprices. Thanks!! -Travissssssssssss Read more
Such a cute and welcoming business. I loved the ordering process once I figured it out. The atmosphere was very welcoming and... the staff was helpful. We went around closing time for lunch and the line wasn?t very long. I do wish the crust on the pizza wasa little more firm, it was so soft and flimsy that the topping fell off when trying to get it out of the box. But other thanthat we loved everything about it. I loved the honey sriracha sauce that was the topping on the Nightmare on Braxie streetpizza. The sauce and ricotta cheese really calmed down the spice of the sriracha. I will be ordering that pizza again. Kid mealswere wonderful, my children loved having their own pizzas and the cookies. I?m glad to have a new location in Berkeley Springsto get pizza. And it?s quick with a reasonable price. Great new business! Read more
Great flavor, but size not as advertised. Ordered two 13 inch pizzas, both were between 9-10 inches. The box is indeed 13... inches, but the pizzas did not come anywhere near that size. Also, they need a system in place so you know when your order isready--maybe a screen with your order number? Just putting all of this out there for quality control purposes. With that said,the flavor was amazing and I will be coming back once they get all the kinks worked out. Read more
Amazing taste and fantastic quality without breaking the bank, a fun and enjoyable atmosphere, and fast service to top it off!... I've eaten here twice and I've absolutely loved the two different pizzas I tried. Plus the locally bottled sodas are deliciousand pair perfectly with the fresh baked pizza! The BBQ Drizzle on the mothman pizza went really well with the lime notes of theSquonk soda ???????????? This place is fantastic and if you're a local to the Panhandle Area or you're just taking a trip onroute 522 I highly recommend making a pitstop at Mythical Pizza! Read more
Love the vibe and atmosphere of the restaurant. I wish there were more portions of the toppings and that they were spread out a... little more, but the pizza was still fantastic. Their cheesy garlic bread is incredible Read more
We probably waited about 30-45 minutes for our pizzas tonight because we got there at the height of the dinner rush, but it was... 100% worth it! Best pizza I've ever had, so glad you guys are finally open and killing it! Can't wait to be back! Read more
Love the neon cryptid theme and youthful vibe this place brings to Berkeley Springs. The pizza options are based on classic... favorites but with quirky and flavorful twists. It's still new (as of fall 2022) so they've got a few kinks to iron out, but thestaff is so friendly and it's obvious they're working hard to meet everyone's needs! We were unable to call in our order, but weplaced it on arrival and it was done in 15 minutes. Plus it was a great price for a customizable pizza!! Read more