Reviews for Bay Ridge Pizza in Brooklyn, NY
Ordered a large margherita pie and it WAS THE WORST PIE EVER. Whole pizza was covered in cheese and there was no sauce or basil... leaves. We asked them about that and they said they ran out of basil. The worker gave me a clueless look when I said I wouldhave went somewhere else if I knew they had no basil or sauce left. WASTE OF MONEY. WORST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD Read more
Best Lasagna I ever had. The guys there were just amazing and very friendly. The ambiance was lovely and the price was very... good. If I come back to New York I'll definitely eat there again. Absolutely recommend ???????? Read more
SOLID slice, 4 out 5. It?s well balanced from tip to crust and nothing about it is wrong. With that said, for me, it does fall... slightly short of just the extra special something. However, there?s enough here to make go in intending to only eat one slicebut then immediately returning for a second. This pizzeria deserves its popularity. I saw a guy eating a slice while sitting inwhat had to be a 70s Lincoln Town Car, so they have a loyal following. I ordered a regular plain slice first, enjoyed itthoroughly, and then returned to try ?a square.? The square definitely has a better more buttery crust. I like that the pricingis fair ($3) and they don?t charge extra for squares. I might not travel from Staten Island just to get their pizza, but I woulddefinitely return if in the Brooklyn area. Read more
No one does authentic vegan pizza the way they make it. Medium pie.
Nothing compares to Bay Ridge Pizza! And I am speaking from experience! A few years ago, my family and I moved out of Brooklyn... (a big mistake) thinking that we could find happiness in Staten Island. Well, Staten Island is beautiful, it's quiet, and thepeople are decent. It reminds me of how Bay Ridge used to be. However, even though many pizza owners left Brooklyn and moved toStaten Island, their pizza stinks! And I have lived on the island for over five years and I have yet to find a great pizzeria!Every now and then I go to Brooklyn for business, and this time I decided to stop by Bay Ridge Pizza, and it's interestingbecause I now don a beard, and through the beard and all, my old friend Gasper, the owner of the establishment, recognized me!He said, "Hey! I haven't seen you in such a long time, but it felt like yesterday since I last saw him. " I told him, "I missyour pizza because it is the absolute best pizza in Brooklyn, NY!" It is actually second to none, and I have tried pizza fromseveral pizzerias. Gasper, his workers, and the cooks are all great people. Gasper even prepares the pizza before baking! Notmany owners do that nowadays! Having said that, you should try their pizza. You won't be disappointed, and their entrees areexcellent too! It is true Italian pizza the way we had it back in the day! Thank you! Read more
Hello everyone , wouldn't recommend this place so much. I ordered chicken parm with ziti. I asked for garlic knots instead of... bread, but they suggested we can put the same sauce on the bread, with no charge that didn't happen. I ask to put a gd amount of cheese, that didn't happen. I asked for all condiments, that didn't happen. We really wanted salt and pepper hat didn'tvhappen. Bread was rock hard, we don't want by o eat it especially with out the garlic sauce. The only thing that had cheeseND sauce was the chicken. They gave us no forks knives or plates or plastic plates, so we bought u them ourselves. My friendsenjoyed there mushroom slices minus the pasta. They weren't even interested. There not really friendly, or genuine. I thinkthere better for pizza. Pasta had no sauce cheese or flavor. The pasta dish was bland. I'm glad I asked for the extracondiments. Won't ever order pasta dishes to expensive and not enough of sauce flavor or cheese. Can't even eat the bread it'sso brick hard. Be careful and take your chance. Take care and love u all Read more
THIS IS THE BEST PIZZERIA IVE EVER BEEN TOO. 10/10 Recommend. ???? Anything and everything you eat here is the best, the quality... in every ingredient, the portion size, the variety, etc. This place is a very inviting and welcoming atmosphere, and iswonderful for people with food allergies such a gluten intolerance and other allergies. They care for their customers, are verycleanly, and so much more. In the pictures are: potato croquettes, Sicilian slice, mozzarella sticks, and a grandma slice. ?? Read more
The Crown Jewel of slices in Bay Ridge. The regular cheese slice was the BEST, most AUTHENTIC, taste of Brooklyn I've had. Their... mesculin salad is my favorite salad from anywhere EVER. I can't get enough of it. Try the ravioli slice (ravioli on top w/ vodkasauce). It sounds strange, but it's quite creative, interesting to actually eat, and delicious. Read more