Reviews for Nicolosi's Pizzeria and Restaurant in Easton, PA

Working remotely today on a nice day near the park at Sullivan Trail. Rode my bicycle over to Nicolosi's for a couple of slices... of Grandma Pizza to go. Fantastic!!! Great flavor, big slices, (I am stuffed) and the sauce was just sweet enough to beperfect!!! Had pepperoni on the slice and I was amazed at how generous they were on the toppings! My new favorite pizzaplace!! These days, post Covid, everyone has an excuse to not satisfy the customer. Not to see a business stand out from therest!! Thank you! Read more

Purchased 3 pepperoni pizzas for dinner tonight There was so much grease on them they were unedible. Won't be eating there again

A few weeks ago I was walking along Sullivan Trail when a random Grubhub driver pulled over on the side of the road next to the... police station and offered me pizza from a canceled order from here. This was honestly some really good pizza, I'll definitelybe back to actually buy pizza from here. Read more

We've been going to Nicolosi's for many years, but much less so over the last year since my wife switched jobs (she used to work... right down the road). In the past it was usually good with the occasional miss. The pizza we got last night, however, was oneof the worst pizzas we have ever had from any establishment. The worst part about it was the crust. The bottom was verylimp/soggy and the entire crust was very tough and rubbery - so much so that my jaw was sore after eating 2 slices. Havingworked in a pizza place all through college, my guess is that there was too much flour in the dough and/or they are pre-saucingthem well in advance of sales during their busy times without oiling the dough first (just guessing though). Regardless,despite being longtime patrons, it will probably be awhile before we give them another chance after last night's majordisappointment. Read more

We were loyalists to Nicolosi's for a long time. However, over the last couple of months when we have ordered from them, we have... been continuously disappointed. We had ordered a Margherita pie tonight, for example. The whole pie was over done. The crust wasburnt on the bottom and the sauce was so dry that you literally couldn't even taste it. The cheese? What cheese? All we couldtaste is the bottom of the burnt pie. Maybe in the future we will go back to Nicolosis, but being continuously disappointeddrove us to buying a pie from Colonial pizza from down in Easton on the same night. Read more

Great food! Ordered one of the Flights I've been seeing all over Facebook with Knots and a Cheesesteak. It was all delicious!... Only downfall is not being able to get delivery the past couple times I called ???? Definitely worth picking up BUT I have a newborn and toddler so would be a tad difficult ???? Read more

Dylan hooked us up with the most amazing pizza flight. We picked four flavors - sausage (andouille) and hot peppers, pepperoni,... ham & pineapple, and his (amazing) version of taco pizza. OMG so good. I wish we had thought to take a picture before wedevoured it. Read more

I ordered a California cheese steak that ended up a mushy mess that didn't fill up the bun. Worst I've ever had! This place... has gone way down hill. Their customer service is worse than the food. Extremely rude. I see that I am not the only onecomplaining about the "kid at the counter." He definitely does NOT treat customers with respect. I refuse to be yelled at bypeople when I am spending my money. No wonder it was empty at lunchtime & dinner. Ater 25 years I will never go back. Shady? The response is a perfect example that they really could care less. Your focus should be on your employees actions and not onmy level of frustration and indignation. It is sad that they feel entitled to treat their customers this way. I did notattack you personally and request the same respect. You can't hurt me. I don't have a business that depends on customersatisfaction. If I had gotten a "great sandwich " this review would have been much different. Note to owner: Or I could havejust gotten a bad sandwich. Read more