Reviews for Nittolo's Seafood & Pizza in Lake Leelanau, MI
The fig jam, goat cheese and nuts were a shining light upon a dead pizza dough and burnt cornmeal. The cornmeal doesn?t need to... be there - let alone burnt. The dough didn?t seem to raise - is it old dough? or maybe it?s a recipe that would be better suitedfor an oven. It is very close to being a good pizza. Unfortunately, for $20, I won?t try again. Read more
There?s a lot of pizza in Traverse/Leelanau County but you?d be hard pressed to find some as good as Nittolo?s. The dough,... ingredients, and technique are legit. The outdoor patio is super charming and the staff were super nice. Lastly, do not pass onthe Caprese salad. Best Caprese I?ve ever had! Read more
Went during Traverse City restaurant week. I was quite impressed. I knew they had good pizza in the other side of the building,... but this dinner was excellent quality. Only fault was some risotto that was so sticky and stiff I left it on the plate.Appetizer was wonderful. The salmon had a perfect sear on it, and a dessert of their famous cannoli, delicious. Read more
We came here because "local friends" of the friends we were traveling with said, " this place is amazing!" So we all went. What... a special dinner we all had. Taylor was our waitress and she was wonderful. Eric Nittolo, the owner spoke with us; he is such anengaging person! Currently both seafood and pizza menus are offered in the main dinning area. There are changes underway, theyare reconfiguring the current space; creating a new space; for a dining experience with the ultimate seven course meal- topdrawer- with limited seating, beginning in May! Something to look forward to! Read more
Holy calamari!! My family and I just had the best calamari ever! Nittolo?s Seafood & Social (and Nittolo?s Pizza) serves... amazing calamari cut in steak strips with peanut pad Thai, ginger slaw and cilantro lime sauce. It is lightly breaded and sotender. The layers of flavors of the sauces makes it the most interesting and delicious calamari we have ever tasted. I had themost delicious, huge Caesar salad with big shavings of Parmesan cheese and crunchy croutons (two types!) piled on top. Thedressing was amazing too! We all shared a tasty pepperoni pizza with the most tangy tomato paste/sauce. The pizza crust isdelicious! Yummy!!! We will definitely be back to try more seafood and pizza ? hopefully very soon! Read more
We had dinner here for the first time, the food, service and and atmosphere was amazing! Tom was our server he was fantastic,... and the owner recommendation the most wonderful bottle of wine! We can?t wait to come back! Read more
Slow start, but it was obvious that it was just they were making the food fresh. It was amazing, we had the firecracker shrimp... and a pizza. Would definitely recommend. Very nice atmosphere, i would like to come back in the evening to see it with thelittle lights on. Read more
Excellent place to eat! A great atmosphere with great staff! We got a variety of pizzas, the crust is incredible!! Highly... recommended! Read more