Reviews for Joey's Tap & Tavern in Millburn, NJ
First time; bad experience. My husband and I came to the place, thinking we would find Clemenza's restaurant. When we noticed... the change, we gave it a try. We ordered 2 ice teas, a chicken parm sandwich and a meat lasagna. We waited about 45 minutes forthe food when when it arrived, we had to leave. The lasagna was all burn, the whole thing tasted like burned and my husband'sparm had absolutely no taste. We were hungry and before waiting any longer, a nice lady came over, apologized and offered toreduce the bill on half. Although things like this can happen, perhaps this was not the best approach to deal with the issue. Myhusband and I drove 30 minutes, waited 45 minutes and got changed about $22 for 2 ice teas. Please take this as a constructivecriticism: Front of the house and back of the house make a restaurant either good in service or good in food. You guys have anice place in a nice area. If you just opened the place, take some time to train your kitchen staff to put an effort in cookingand produce quality food, that would make people come back even if they wait a long time for the food to come to the table. Goodluck in your new business. Read more
Had a delicious meal tonight. Ended up here accidentally as our expected destination was unexpectedly closed. Owner/ hostess was... very pleasant and accommodating to our group that was from out of state. The rice balls, chicken, salmon, and Sunday dinner areall recommended Read more
Great experience today! We had our nieces baby shower and everything was delicious! Their party planner Carolyn was so easy to... work with and very accommodating to all our needs. Highly recommend! Read more
Hands down the best restaurant in NJ. The Chilean Sea Bass is out of this world as are all of the fish options here. Pizza every... Friday night and Sunday night sauce. One of the last remaining Italian stallion establishments. Beautiful! Read more
Food is okay, service not so much. They forgot my salad, the dishes came out at different times, they got the dessert order... wrong. Make sure you ask the for the prices of the specials before ordering one. We were surprised to get hit with a $34 chargefor a stuffed filet of sole (not a particularly expensive fish). The $28 salmon was okay but tiny leaving me hungry. The ownersseem like very nice people so I feel a little uneasy about leaving this midling review. Perhaps we just got the wrong dishes. Read more
A great place to stop in and have a nice dinner. Great staff and friendly service. You will not be disappointed.
Have had the privilege of eating there three times each time better and better we had amazing lunch yesterday prices reasonable... and the food was delicious.. The spicy chicken meatballs are a must also enjoyed the chicken Parm with spaghetti. My friend andI love to dine and enjoyed our Vino we didn’t feel rushed. So glad we found you and that you were open for lunch we will beback! Read more
No french onion soup, the chicken balls I got 2 orders instead of splitting one and one was beef balls and still got charged for... them after sending them back saying I didn't want them! Read more