Reviews for The Hills Tavern in Millburn, NJ
The Good - Food was delicious. I had the steak salad and the steak in it was amazing. But... The Bad - while our waitress was... nice, we waited over 15 minutes after putting our menus down before having to flag her down after she passed us a few times.After we got our food she didn't come back unless we flagged her down for ketchup and then the check. I had a glass of water...no wait staff gave me a refill. The Ugly - Whoever designed the decor for this place doesn't know about acoustics. When Iheard someone from the back of the restaurant tap their silverware over and over to get their toddler's attention when I wassitting in the front of the restaurant I knew there was a problem. Why would anyone choose tiles on the walls of the maindining room? Sound bounces off these tile walls (think NYC subway platforms) and stays in the room longer due to the size of theroom and the high ceiling. This causes sound to stick around longer and explains why others call this restaurant loud. Read more
Came here with two other couples on a Saturday night. The restaurant wasnt too busy and we were given a table towards the... back. The food was delicious. We started with oysters and shrimp cocktail. Then for the main courses, we had a combination ofshrimp, flat bread, pasta with bolognes, steak.. Everything was delicious and well portioned. My only complaint was the servicewas a little slow even though the restaurant wasn't that busy but that happens sometimes. Luckily we were with great company andit wasn't an issue. I will certainly be back again Read more
Good sizes for the food. The colossal pretzel is perfect for groups over 5 (it's very large). Street parking and some parking... lots are free on Sundays. You can make reservations if you need. Small enough that it's very easy to get a waiter for whateveryou need. Read more
Food is pretty bland... Portions are enormous.. Went on valentines day as a walk in and they sat us right away. Waiter was... somewhat helpful guiding us with his recommendations but failed to tell us the portion sizes. Beer list was exceptional. Read more
Great service, but the band couldn't get the microphone right. Kept having the screeching sound, and ruined the evening for... us. Way too loud for such a small place Read more