Reviews for Gallo Pizza & Italian Restaurant in New Oxford, PA
I've been curious to try Gallo's. My husband is Italian and his face after the first bite of his stuffed shells said it all! I... had a California cheesesteak. Fantastic flavor and quality for both of our meals. We'll be back! Read more
Ate lunch there today around 1 pm. The good-service was fast, portion size very good and prices very reasonable. The not so... good-server was either overwhelmed or disinterested. Very mechanical. There was another young lady there who didn?t help outin the dining room but sat on a chair between the pizza oven and kitchen except when cashiering. The chicken in the chickenparmigiana was good as was the cheese but the roll, pizza sauce and pizza crust all lacked flavor. Very bland. Dough used forrolls and pizza needs more oil and sugar during the mixing stage to add flavor. Sauce needs additional spices. Tables weresomewhat close together. One loud customer can be heard throughout entire dining room. Read more
Great little place. Service is good, everyone is very friendly. Clean table coverings, removed after each patron finishes. ... Food is served hot and very tasty. We have dined here several times and have always had a good experience. Only, negative isthe place is small and when filled it is a bit noisy. But great food and service and good prices overweight the noisy room. Read more
Once again, Gallo's has done an amazing job!! Lunch consisted of a 2 topping personal pizza (mushrooms & onions), and their soup... & sandwich special (Italian Wedding soup & half cheeseburger sub) Delicious! ?????????? Read more
The most excellent service and delicious food. I had a wonderful white pizza customized to my preferences and the cheese cake,... oh yum. Read more
Tonight my husband and I went for dinner. Salad and bread sticks came with our entree. But we had antipasto freddo as an... appetizer. Wow it was big! Very tasty. My husband had the spaghetti Allo Scoglio which was spaghetti with scallops, shrimp,mussels and clams in a light marinara sauce. I had a little taste and it was good. I had the Veal Parmesan. I wanted my veal tohave light sauce on it. But the came out smothered in sauce. The young lady there took it back and had it was remade withoutsauce. Which I asked for. The dish was so very good along with the spaghetti. They do give you a lot of food.There wasleftovers to be enjoyed at another time. Probably for lunch. They really care for their customers and it was excellent after Igot my dish corrected. We will be back. Read more
Good local italian food. Reasonable prices and good service. Fresh bread good pizza and bolis. Other good stuff on the menu too.... Tonight I had the Pasta ala Gallo which was a baked pasta in bolognese sauce with cheese. I loved the rich meaty sauce. Therewas plenty that my pasta didn't dry out but it wasn't drowned in it either. My wife had the chicken parmesan. She likes thebright fresh tomatoey yet not overly acidic red sauce they serve. With garlic bread and tossed salads, we always enjoy eatinghere. Read more
Everything was very good! Will be back in the near future. Got the stuffed shells and garden salad with garlic bread. Highly... recommend! Read more