Reviews for Toloache in New York, NY
Busy, friendly place that looks like they have a regular following - judging by the many warm greetings and hugs with the... manager (or owner). Service was good. Food was delicious, especially the sweet plantain side. Read more
I thought I give this place a second chance but its still way too expensive for the portions. The worse sweet Maduro ( fried... bananas) $10 I’ve ever had and I’ve had the best, so dark and unpleasant presentation who knows how long the frying oil wasin that bucket. I also had Camarones Toloache $35.00 swimming in liquid see the photo) this dish is roasted garlic Shrimp withcrispy tortilla, black beans, ( maybe a pinch of beans) Totally a disaster. I wouldn’t never order from there again the pricesare astronomical for the portions. Delivery food from them doesn’t arrive properly it gets mushy if something supposed to becrispy. I don’t recommend delivery. They should adjust their prices according to portions. Two people ( 3 dishes $100 with tipwithout any drinks. ) my husband got theBurrito Toloache, Steak $20.00 Rice, beans, steak, Mexican cheeses, pico, guacamole &salsa verde it was ok. Read more
Went here for date night and had an incredible time!! Hostess/Manager was so sweet and welcoming. Drinks were delicious. Our... server Eli was knowledgeable about the menu and took the time to explain his recommendations to us. He was great! The food wasdelicious - I was so so full from eating so much! I had the Camarones (Shrimp) and my boyfriend had the Tacos De Costilla &Tuetano (Short Rib Tacos) Definitely recommend!! Read more
The atmosphere was so welcoming (and yes they do check vaccination cards :) !!), the service was incredible, and the food was... absolutely divine!! I asked for a light margarita and they were kind enough to actually oblige. Presentation was on point andoverall a wonderful experience. Read more
Way too expensive for mediocre food. Quesadilla was probably about 7 inches and resembled a personal pan pizza.$17 Chicken... enchiladas had lettuce on them and the chicken had no flavor. For it being a Plato fuerte at $24 it also should have come withrice and beans. Guacamole was so cold- so you could tell it's pre-made. All it tasted of was lime juice- probably to keep itfrom going brown. Drink tasted non alcoholic $16 Service wasn't great. And someone was using an electric saw on the outsidedining cubicles while we were having dinner out there. I would never go back to this whitewashed fake Mexican place. I don'tknow who gave it so many great rating. I guess people who do not know what really good Mexican food is. This is not it. Read more
Mexican International Gourmet Restaurant. Large space to Take inn attendant diligence and kindly personnel. Sidewalk space to... drink and eat your favorite classic Mexican dishes. Delivery Avaliable. Read more
Went here for a birthday dinner, and the food was delicious! There is an outdoor seating area with private mini rooms to eat at... that look fun, but we dined in. Our recommendations are the guacamole (we stick with mild and loved it) and the enchiladas. Someof my favorite enchiladas in NYC actually! The staff was very attentive, we got our food quickly. We made our reservationthrough open table and there was no issue. Bathrooms were clean. Overall a very positive experience! Read more
Excellent!, Fresh Guac& Chips . Good Service and great atmosphere.. I recommend the Carne Asada and Los Tacos d Birria.