Reviews for Celestino's Ny Pizza & Pasta in Rocklin, CA

As a native New Yorker, I know what NY pizza is. Celestinos filled every expectation...thin crust..great taste..LIKE HOME... ..UNTIL last two visits. It tastes different...crust way too thick..blah taste...not enough cheese and not greasy, (like NYpizza SHOULD be). What a letdown. Read more

Update: Changed rating from four stars to three. I ordered the same thing as my previous review - great crunch, evenly spread... out toppings. Sadly the other reviewer was correct - they changed their crust recipe and possibly the marinara sauce. It's likehaving pizza with a head cold. The addictive element is gone. Not sure why you'd mess with a recipe 25+ years old? PreviousReview: They started up in Chico and lucky for us they brought it down here to feed your face. Great pizza by the slice -crunchy crust and tasty toppings. If they have the "Godfather" out for pizza by the slice - grab one! The "Tom Jones" and the"White" pizzas are my usual choice. The meatball sandwich is also something to give a go. The menu has something for prettymuch everyone...salads, calzone, pasta. Read more

Being from NY, I tried the pizza recently and it was great, like NY pizza. Went in yesterday and the pizza was terrible:... terrible crust, very little sauce and skimpy toppings compared to initial visit. I called and spoke to manager and he told me itwas my problem. H e admitted that they recently CHANGED their recipe and reduced the toppings and sauce, etc. So it isn't me,but he didn't care what I thought of the change. Last time for me. The rest of the pizza went into the trash. It may have beenNY pizza in the past, but no more. The search goes on. Read more

I got three pizza to try out: white sauce pizza, Hawaiian pizza, and mushroom pizza. The white sauce pizza and Hawaiian pizza... had a good crunch due to its thin crust, each bite the texture carrys. The mushroom pizza was a bit soggy, wasn't crunchy as theothers but it was less oily than the other two with a strong mushroom and Italian seasoning flavor. The white sauce had a stronggarlic taste with Italian seasoning, and the cheese on top of it helped mellow it down. Even with the downside in some pizzawith the inconsistent texture, the flavor still carries. Definitely a go to place for a NY Style Pizza Read more

Great pizza place. Plenty of room inside and a patio. Staff was very friendly and inside was very clean. I dont know the whole... menu but I walked in, they had some ready made pies (buy by the slice) with descriptions. Bought me few slices and even addedsome ingredients..they threw them bad boys back in the oven and few minutes later I was eating some great pizza!! I had a sliceof Tom Jones (pepperoni, sausage n Canadian bacon) I also had a slice of Mushroom and added some pepperoni...AND IT WASAWSOME!! I could've eating the mushroom itself again...so good. I also was able to buy a pint of beer and watch some baseballon several TVs inside. I will be back! This i guarantee ???? Read more

My favorite Pizza in the area. Quality ingredients make the best pizzas and you can tell that Celstino's does not skimp on the... quality or quantity of the ingredients they use in their pizzas. They have slices to go if you want to grab a quick bite but Ialways get myself a Pepperoni Special (Pepperoni, Tomato, Garlic, Basil) or a Danny Devito (Pepperoni, Ricotta, Garlic) and theyalways come out fresh and the crust is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside with lots of fresh toppings. Service isalways great and they do have a big dining area with lots of TVs playing sports so if you're looking for a place with good pizzaand a relaxing, fun atmostphere, look no further than Celstino's! Read more

First time here and my impressions. Friendly staff. Take out orders take ~15 mins after placing order. There's a gentlemen who... calls your name out once your order is ready for pickup. He's quite loud and it really helps in a crowded place. I ordered thecombo specialty pizza. Med. sized and it cost ~$27. The pizza looks good. The pie crust is good but the middle section isundercooked... and not crispy. You can definitely fold the pizza New York style. The ingredients from what I can tell is fresh.Didn't quite tasted the pizza sauce. Either not much sauce or the flavor is too mild for me. So my experience is average. I willtry the other offerings next time. I believe you can order pizza per slice here so you can try a lot in one visit. The inside ofthe restaurant is nice and clean. I see the staff clean the tables often. I did noticed they have a lot of pizza boxes. Some arein the main dining room as well. Read more

Most likely the best legit pizza in the Roseville/Rocklin area. I like that they don't use too much cornmeal on the bottom like... a lot of NY pizzerias do. Their "classics" pizzas are true to NY style with just a few toppings. My favorite is the PepperoniSpecial (pictured) with red sauce (which is awesome), mozzarella, pepperoni, diced garlic, basil, and fresh diced tomatoes.Killer crust and the perfect amount of toppings. The Danny Devito is another one of their killer "classics" pizzas. Do yourselfa favor and try this place. Read more