Reviews for The 75th Street Inn in Salem, WI
What an experience! We were in last night and had the cutest waitress ever named Ashley who was so sweet and smiling the whole... time. She made jokes and had us feeling so at home. I couldn't say enough about how nice it is to see young people lovingtheir job and not feel like they are there just for a paycheck. She really went out of her way to make our dining experiencewonderful. I have posted on my Instagram as well and since I have over a million followers, I am sure there will be quite apresence to come with new faces. Hopefully Ashley will be available for everyone lol. Oh yeah, The food was great also. HIGHLY recommend the Brussel Sprouts appetizer Read more
This use to be a favorite unfortunetly it's gone downhill. Reduced menu, the fish came out over down, chicken strip were... soggy.It took 40 minutes to get the food. Waitress was good but we won't be back Read more
We stopped in after shopping for an RV st New Gen RV down the road. Menu options were good, beers on tap, service was great! ... Our food was really good too! Will definitely stop in again when we're up north. Read more
Found this on the way out of Lake Geneva while looking for a local restaurant on the way to the interstate. Started with, no... joke, some of the best hot pretzels I ever had. It?s been a while since I had some that were both cooked perfectly and had agreat taste. The kids? chicken tenders were also very good, ?always fresh? they claimed. The Italian Beef sandwich was alsopretty good. Prices were reasonable and service was fine too. Read more
First time visit as we are new to living in the area!! Loved walking in and feeling right at home!! The staff are warm and... welcoming. I had the pot roast sandwich and the Brussels Chips. Both of these were incredible. The bread with the sandwichtasted as fresh as it just came out of the oven, while pot roast was as good as your families favorite recipe. The Brusselschips tasted incredible for sure!! My guests had the steak salad - steak was tender and juicy and the greens were fresh asthough they came out of a garden. Our other guest had Italian beef with sweet potato fries. She said it was delicious. Needless to say our plates were each clean and generous portions for sure!! Ethan was the server and was quick and nice andfriendly. A great first visit!! We shall be back Read more
What a find, we have lived in Kenosha over 20 years, passed this place numerous times and never went in. 2 weeks ago was our... first visit. We love this little pub. The service is fantastic the young ladies are friendly and knowledgeable about the menuitems. The first time in we had the Irish Egg Rolls, they were so good, I said, I'd eat those as an entree any time. Theylooked freshly prepared, and so tasty. The entrées we had was the French Onion Steak Sandwich and a special of the day,Braised Short Ribs with Caramelized Pickled Onions. The steak sandwich was cooked perfectly, beef tenderloin with caramelizedonions and crispy onion strings on the side. The onion strings were crispy, flakey and not oily like other onion strings we'vehad. The short rib sandwich was full of flavor the pickled onions added a nice touch to the taste of the sandwich. Today wereturned, they had a special appetizer Deep Fried Brussel Sprout Leaves with Chopped Bacon and Balsamic Glaze....it was amazing! Our lunch today was the Nurse Mary only with Grilled Chicken Breast on a Toasted Pretzel Bun, this sandwich was packed withspinach, fresh sliced avocado and it was delicious! The Chicken was juicy and had great flavor. I chose the French Green Beansas my side, they were a nice bright green, cooked to a perfect al dente, seasoned perfectly, they had a nice nutty flavor. Their special of the day was a Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich, it was amazed allspice! It had a nice spice to it, a littlesweetness from the brown sugars, the the vinegar from the pickles added a nice balance to the overall flavor of the sandwich. The sweet crunchy coleslaw added a nice crunch texture and sweetness to the sandwich. We decided on a homemade dessert tofinish off the meal, Deep Fried Bread Pudding...OMG! That dessert was one of the best desserts I've ever had! I was homemadebread pudding cut into large cubes, deep fried, tossed in cinnamon sugar topped with vanilla ice cream and drizzle Read more
We stopped here for dinner on our return route home to Illinois and what a great delicious decision that was. Nice menu offers,... fair prices, good size portions, and excellent taste/flavors. The tortilla chips with spinach dip, fantastic. My daughter hadthe grilled salmon she said was cooked just right with a delicious side of green beans, potato soup and salad. I had the turkeyavacado burger on a pretzel bun with spinach instead of lettuce, accompanied by perfect sweet potato fries, just wonderful. Theyput half an avocado on this huge burger, unlike other places that give you a slice or two. For dessert had the pineapplecheesecake which was out of this world. The server's were really friendly and helpful. The day after at work I told my friendshow good this place was and there saying "You just found this place now, we all have known about way before and your right, it'sgreat.???? Read more
We have been longtime customers and I can honestly say the food was better during the height of the pandemic. Now the menu has... changed and the quality of the food and service simply isn?t the same. Mind you, we are well aware of how hard it is to survivein this industry, post-pandemic. For this visit we started with bottles beers, asking for glasses. The glasses were loaded withspots and I even noticed the bartender looking them over before she sent them out. I would have had them rewashed or sent outnew ones. For food we decided to change things up a bit and ordered their bone-in wings per the recommendation of our server,asking them to be cooked on the more well-done (crispier) side. They were average with not a lot of meat on them, but the combosauce was good. I ordered a cup of chili with with all the fixings. It came out lukewarm and was ridiculously thick, to thepoint that I could not finish it. Then we decided to split the southwestern steak wrap, with tater tots as our side. Neither oneof us could truly describe the funky taste of the steak and the rest of the wrap was dry with no flavor. The tater tots tastedas though they had been fried in old oil. We each took a bite and pushed our plates away. I have never experienced such a poormeal here. Our server was quite attentive and felt bad about the meal, but it was not their fault and we expressed that to them.The server was kind enough to remove the main meal from our check, even though we did not ask for that. We thanked them kindly,paid and left. Overall, we were disappointed because this has always been one of our go-to restaurants and we fully supportedthem throughout the pandemic. I was even in by myself a few months ago, sat at the bar and had my usual delicious Wisconsinburger with an old fashioned. We hope to return down the line, but it will take awhile. Read more