Reviews for Old Mexico Cantina and Grill in Sturgeon Bay, WI

Authentic and delicious mexican food. Fresh Guacamole was just too good. We took a couple of items with a mixture of rice and... beans and veggies and it felt very different from what we are used to like Chipotle and Qdoba Read more

Our first time eating here and all I can say is WOW! The friendly and fast service from being seated immediately to getting... drinks within minutes to being there to take our order very timely was nothing short of amazing and actually, refreshing! Somany places lack what Old Mexico has to offer, great service! I can't say it enough! The food, outstanding and served fast andHOT! Prices are very reasonable and the atmosphere is very charming Mexican decor and music is fun!! All in all I feel wediscovered a goldmine in this visit! Their roadside sign is not lit so watch carefully for them. Enjoy! Read more

Just ate there today. Food and service was great. Pretty cool looking restaurant inside too. Lots of color and paintings are... cool. So are the chairs. Get the grande burrito, you wont regret it. Id eat here all the time if i lived in sturgeon bay. Read more

Food was good. Pricing seemed a bit high compared to what I would expect from this style of restaurant in the area. Sauces... seemed to lack spice which is only a negative if you like your food hot. Mojito special was excellent and priced nicely at$7.50 (normally 10) Read more

Great Mexican food! My wife and I are in town to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Mexican sounded good for our first night... after a day of driving. Old Mexico was great! I had the Brasa tacos. The seasoning really set these tacos apart and they hadgreat guacamole. The service was a little slow but we weren?t in any big hurry. The chips were also a little tough andunseasoned. Overall a great experience. Read more

We had fresh Guacamole prepared at the table, and Enchiladas Del Mar and Chimichangas. So delicious! We tried Margaritas and... Mojitos. Guess what, also delicious! Wait staff were helpful and attentive. We walked in at 5 pm and it was easy to get a seat.By 6 pm, there were many full tables, but still a few spots were open. It is a good-sized restaurant. I gave the place 4 starsrating because the ladies room was closed on the night we were there. Read more

Old Mexico is OUTSTANDING! This was my 1st time eating here and the food and service blew me outta the water! When we arrived we... were greeted right away and seated in under 5 minutes without a reservation. They ask us what we wanted to drink as they sat usand in no time they brought our drinks and a basket of tortilla chips with salsa, which were also amazing. The food here is allauthentic and the portion sizes are just ginormous. I went hungry and left with leftovers that lasted me 2 more days! The staffare all very polite and very friendly. All in all I can't say anything bad about Old Mexico. I would recommend Old Mexico toeveryone, singles, couples, families, and groups. Read more

It was my husband birthday and my birthday weekend and what a great place to celebrate. It?s been about 3 years since I have... had a strawberry margarita so I ordered a medium and my husband a large. Holy wow they where huge, and very delish. Then theyhave a waiter come to the table and ask if you want fresh guacamole. The guacamole is so fresh and made for a great appetizer. Igot street tacos and my husband fajitas. I think we should of shared. Large portions and the meat was very tender along withgreat flavor. They where short staffed like a lot of places but they did a fantastic job and made sure we where taken care of.It?s nice to write a positive review. It makes us want to come back. Read more