Reviews for Tanners Boathouse in Tannersville, NY
Nice atmosphere and friendly staff though food is a tad underwhelming. Very large portion of fries but the fish portion in my... fish & chips was very small and also under seasoned. Very fresh and hot and crispy though. Read more
I wish I could say Tanners boathouse was a priceless experience, but it was actually $93 for a small piece of fish on a roll. ... Anyone who likes the fish has clearly never had any before. Shrek?s Boathouse is also great if you?re looking to not over eat.I finished my small fried fish pieces within 2 minutes and was not in the mood to eat the hill of fries. My advice: save your$30 on the lobster roll, buy a fishing net, and go catch one yourself. Then at least you know you?ll be getting your money?sworth- but don?t go fishing in the swamp next to the restaurant. Read more
The fries were the best part of the meal, they deserve the 2 stars. The burger was small and the lobster roll was $30 for a... below average portion of meat. It was an interesting concept here. Maybe it was an off day Read more
Super nice staff. Excellent lobster roll. (Other food is great, too.) Strong margaritas. Classic rock sets the mood. Great for... an afternoon in Tannersville. Read more
The best lobster roll I?ve ever had. Super fresh and delicious. Makes this Maryland boy blue crab lover a convert. Great... atmosphere and lovely staff. Very well managed establishment. Watermelon margaritas to die for. Wish I could give it six stars. Read more
Really great atmosphere by the lake. The workers are incredibly helpful and friendly. Had a wonderful fish and chips meal with a... few GREAT cocktails (thank you Gwen) off the beaten path ! Let?s go! Read more
Wonderful location with various seafood themed offerings. Lobster roll and clam chowder were good. You can sit outside... overlooking a nice pond. The boathouse rents canoes and kyacks and there is a beach with a lifeguard. Read more
Very expensive sub-par food. $20 for fish and chips which was more like chips and four small pieces of fish... $10 for bland... Mac n Cheese in a cup and $32 for a tasteless mini lobster roll. Would never recommend this place! Read more