Reviews for Eddie Joe's Icehouse in West Point, IN
We like this place. Good bbq without having to drive 500 miles.
We've been fans of Edie Joe's for several years now, both dining in before the pandemic, getting take out on the weekends, and... even catering for events. The food has always been great and we would recommend! The one area where it's been a bitdisappointing in our experience is missing items from our order when we do take out - we've ordered extra bbq sauce (which is anadditional charge) and they aren't included, sides have been missing, and even the muffins. This happens almost every time, evenwhen I've added notes to online orders. The staff has always been apologetic about missing items and ask us to come back topickup, but it's a 20 minute drive one way for us. We hope orders will be double checked so this doesn't continue to happen tous or others in the future. Read more
Food was absolutely amazing! Everything was absolutely delicious! The chicken was a bit under done, but they immediately sent it... back and brought us chicken that was thoroughly cooked. They were very busy, and as a homecook I can completely understand. Toend the night, I was careless and left my phone on the table...a kind gentleman (possibly owner) brought it out to us! Thatgesture just put them above the 5 star mark for me! Read more
Excellent food and service as always. The 4-stack enchiladas were amazing. Also had a piece of chocolate lava cake. Omfg. Top... recommendations. Read more
Tried this place out for the first time and it was fantastic!My brisket had great flavor and was cooked to perfection, the... wife's steak was even more delicious! Can't wait to go back and try some of the other great dishes I saw! Read more
What a surprise. Eddie Joe's has amazing barbeque, sweet sides, a down home atmosphere, and People's Brewery on draft. The sweet... potato muffin is especially good with the pecan butter. Staff is friendly and the chef visited our table. Will definitely beback. Read more
What a random find! We went to Eddie Joe's after the Purdue Christmas Show. Driving up in the dark I thought I made a... reservation at a local bar. But this place is fantastic- great brisket, top notch pizza (if you're lucky enough to go on a pizzanight). We tried the sliders too - a great intro to their meats. The stuffed jalapenos are huge! A little loud but no more thansome of my other favorite places. Super friendly staff too. I heard the 1st Sunday of the month is a bloody mary bar... we willbe back to check it out & more of the menu! Read more
Our waitstaff was wonderful - attentive and friendly. Made us feel welcome and was great with the children in our party. I had... the ribs - tasty and moist - my only complaint would be I had to eat them with a fork because they fell off the bone easily.Sweet potato fries and nachos for the table were quickly gobbled up. Nice selection of beer, including local brews ( the peanutbutter stout was great). We were celebrating a family member and the staff made us feel good about being there. While it’s alittle out of town, if your on campus it’s about the same drive as crossing town to the mall or the 65 exit in Lafayette. Iwill come back next time I’m in town. Read more