Reviews for Stromboli's New York Pizzeria in Windermere, FL

New owners been a delight the last ones we racist. As far as the New York style goes they could be a little crispier but most of... the people around here wouldn?t appreciate that (they complain about grease on New York style like go to papa John?s Karen) Iask for it a lil well done and it?s perfect. Read more

Always fast and outstanding customer service, they finally brought New York Style Pizza to Florida and the prices are amazing.... 100% recommend to visit Read more

Amazing pizza !! I work near by and I order to eat there literally everyday !! Best costumer service in Windermere & such a home... feeling when I step in the store , I was born and raised in the Bronx and this food hits all the way home !! Read more

"Fuzzy logic." Now you tell me how this makes sense: busy Friday night, waiting 30 minutes for an order, ok, that checks out.... But, upon the cheese pizza coming out of the oven they realized they had messed it up and had to remake the pizza. Sure,mistakes will happen, that's understandable, especially on a busy Friday. Where this adventure goes sideways is in this nextpart: "we messed up the cheese and have to remake it. But it'll be at the back of the line so it'll be at least 45 minutesbefore it gets into the oven." I actually had to confirm that statement twice I was so taken aback. That logic is unacceptable.Do better. You messed up a cheese pizza and then compounded the problem 10 fold with whatever that failure in thought processingwas. Maybe their food is good, no idea, I left. Other than stressed out by high volume they seemed like nice people at least, sothere's a plus. Read more

Best pizza in the area for sure. Tastes almost exactly like my favorite pizza place in NYC. I wish so many rude entitled... customers weren?t lowering their score, some of these reviews are ridiculous ???? complaining that they were busy on NYE.Seriously, the pizza is good and worth the wait and price. The chocolate cake is amazing too. Read more

A very nice family run pizza place! I had one of their daily specials which consisted of two slices with one topping and a... fountain drink, I opted for bottled water. The pizza was quick fresh and delicious and they even had some Mikes hot honey to addto the slices! You could tell the family that makes pizzas together stays together. There was a very nice, polite young man whowas attending the customers and taking the orders. The family who appeared to be maybe a dad or granddad who was the mastercraftsman, then his kids or grandkids were helping in the back! Anyways very nice to see and the food was awesome, the place wasclean. Only thing is curb appeal as it is located in the strip area of cornerstone and they have a sign missing, but don?t letthat detour you it was great! Read more

I have to be fair and consistent with pizza ratings. If Antica Pizza in Maitland is a 5 star, then this is 2 star. The... employees were very nice and the pizza was prepared on time. There is nothing personal with this rating. The dough was floppy(no backbone) and the slices were very oily (requiring a quick napkin mopping). The cheese and sauce tasted ok. So, nothingreally wrong, just a very "bar pie" experience. If you need a quick pie resembling the NY style....go for it, but better pies inthe area. Read more

I?ve been going here for about 7 years or so and I absolutely love their pizza but the thing that irks me so much hence my 3... star review is that when you order their spaghetti, they give you one little spoonful of sauce. It doesn?t even cover half thenoodles?!? Then you have to pay $1.60 for extra sauce and that still doesn?t even cover it. Not having sauce that covers thewhole pasta is unacceptable. We?ve ordered the spaghetti over 10 times and it?s always this way. We are finally done wasting ourmoney on this. Also, they don?t offer curbside pickup during a global pandemic. Read more