Reviews for Mayflower Seafood Restaurant Greenville in Winterville, NC

It is interesting that several months ago the food was pretty good. However, my recent to go meals were disgusting. I ordered... two meals. Both of these meals were not edible. The fish was undercooked and mushy. The scollops had hair in them (not myhair). I called that night and no one answered the phone. I called the next day and told the manager what happened and he putme on eternal hold. He kept picking up and then just putting me back on hold. I stayed on hold for over 45minutes and then justgave up. There are much better places to eat in this area that actually have management that care about the quality of the foodthey serve. Don?t waste your time or money at this establishment. Read more

I went there Sunday to celebrate my birthday. The food was delicious. The manager Jr. was very polite and accommodating. He... corrected an issue we had with NO hesitation. I really appreciate quality customer service like that because it doesn't reallyexist anymore. Many businesses now don't care about the customers and it shows in the product snd services they give. ThanksMayflower for a wonderful experience and a HUGE shout out to Jr. He is phenomenal!!!! Read more

I love the seafood platter that I've ordered except for the deviled crab. I think it's too garlicky for my taste. Customer... service is nice however it took a little bit of time to get our food served. I saw folks get served first when we arrived/sat toour seats before them. Still, I think it's a nice place to dine in with kids. Love the aquarium ?? Read more

The farther I go the better Mayflower gets I?ll start with customer service from beginning to end it was good better then most... places nowadays they had everything I ordered and the food wasn?t burnt like some of the other Mayflowers dirty grease or justkeeping in the fryer too long if your in the area this one is well worth the stop less your familiar and you already know Read more

Pre pandemic I liked this place. I was appalled at how much it has changed for me. The scallops were rubbery and hard. Shrimp... did not taste like shrimp. The croaker was over cooked. They only thing worth eating was the baked potato that I paid extrafor. Read more

First got our drinks and ordered a salad. Didn't get the salads until the food come out at the same time. Didn't like that,... should have gotten the salad way before the main course. Ordered the broiled Mayflour Special. It had way to much butter on theplate of food. It had so much the food could have slid clean off the plate. The jumbo shrimp were not jumbos at all, med size atbest. Over all I think I won't be ordering that plate ever again. Maybe fried would have been better. Read more

We are new to Greenville North Carolina. we just moved here last November. this was our first visit to the Mayflower seafood... restaurant. I grew up on good seafood in South Carolina. This is a definite oldie but goodie restaurant. The seafood is fresh,with a calabash style. The service was awesome. for this quality of food I was surprised at such the reasonable prices. evenwith the restaurant having a full bar liquor license. The bar didn?t seem to be in operation. There was a Very nice family feel.The restaurant even had 60s and 70s music playing, and not very loud so you could still be able to hear each other talk at yourtable. i?m hoping to Mayflower seafood restaurant Will be in business for many years to come. We will certainly be frequentcustomers. Read more

The food was decent here, ive never really had anything too bad although at my last trip i tried something new, i got the fried... captain Smiths combo with greenbeans and french fries, the combo comes with a nice amount of popcorn shrimp, dome oysters, somescallops, a deviled crab, and a pice of flounder. I dont have many complaints other then the deviled crab was salty and thegreenbeans had no flavor, they wernt seasoned and by the taste they wernt salted or peppered, i had to do thst myself which isnttoo bad, it alowed me to pick how much i wanted but still a little something would help them. I do have one more complaintthough, the fried flounder was very thin and very very crunchy, there was alot of just fried batter on the ends which somepeople like but personally i dont. Read more